When a doofus says a developer needs to sell X number of games on the Wii to be profitable, I all laugh accordingly. However, when Reggie says developers need to sell 1 million copies, on the record, in an interview with the New York Times, I first scratch my head and pray that this is not accurate, for it has dire implications for the entire video game community.
Today, in a follow up to those NYT comments, Fils-Aime “clarified” his remarks during an interview with Wired. “The fact is, there’s no single magic number that defines profitability for a game,” Fils-Aime said. “It’s all based on the level of investment, based on the price point, and so it’s unfortunate that I was misquoted in that article.”
The NYT is sticking by its quote, although the reporter did blog that Nintendo contacted him immediately after the story was published to clarify the remark. “The company wrote me to say that it meant that publishers can make a profit selling fewer than one million copies of a particular game. Nintendo declined to be any more specific about a number,” wrote Bits blogger Matt Richtel.
I sure hope the magic number is not 1 million, and not just for Nintendo’s sake. Case in point, Wii games are exponentially cheaper to develop than their Xbox 360/PS3 cousins, whose best sellers claim about 1 million to 3 million sold (not shipped, Sony) in the their first few months (Metal Gear Solid 4, 3.89 mil life-to-date, for example). If Wii games need 1 million to be profitable, the development industry, as a whole, is sick as a dog right now. Especially in this awful economy. Again, I hope Reggie was just misquoted.
knew you'd be interested in that! (i feel so helpful)
if the nyt guy is sticking to his guns, i'm going to doubt reggie was misquoted, but that he's backpedaling because it's bad business to state a number like that.
to "clarify" that there is no magic number isn't a clarification at all. of course it depends on the game. the only way to interpret his original statement is as some sort of median or mean.
The original article was full of mistakes, not least of which was the use of NPD numbers to talk about million selling Wii games (hence why we're getting the 16 million sellers from NPD, rather than the 73 million sellers from Iwata at GDC).
Anyway, this is all a technicality to justify a piece written with a conclusion around which the 'facts' had to fit. Technically, if Fils-Aime said that Wii games can be profitable selling less than one million, then one 'could' infer that 1 million sales was the 'break even' point. A more reasonable interpretation, however, would be that competitors consoles required sales of greater than 1 million to make a profit, unlike Nintendo.
Really, really bad journalism. Of course, the gaming press is just quoting it all verbatim, rather than doing any kind of critical analysis. Such is the state of the media in this modern world: sensationalism, regurgitated press releases and willful misinterpretation have replaced reporting and intelligent analysis.
Haha, sounds like Reggie accidentally let slip some internal jargon. As in, unless Nintendo knows they'll sell a million, why even bother with a new IP.
Well it's interesting because they don't directly quote him on it, and instead paraphrase his statement. Perhaps what he was implying was that for a high level investment-high profile game you need to sell about a million units across the world for your game to reach a reasonable return on investment, which many companies would use as a more important measure of profitability. $1,000,001 made from a $1,000,000 investment is profitable, but the money could have been more effectively spent on something else. One needs to consider the time value of profit for a given amount of investment.
This is a far cry from the article's statement (which is somewhat coloured) and the quote of 16 games selling better than 1 million on Wii is grossly disingenuous when you consider that NPD only tracks American sales, and internationally over 70 Wii games have reached this mark. As we all know, plenty of Wii games cost next to nothing to make, and most likely can earn decent money on poor sales (hence their proliferation), and Reggie almost certainly wasn't referring to the RE0 'ports' of the world.
Perhaps this may explain Ubisoft's behaviour. Red Steel was a high level investment game (for the Wii anyway) that sold decently (over a million units) despite being average to poor (by most review standards). Despite it making some money (apparently), Ubisoft canned virtually all proper Wii development and turned into the première drivel factory. Either way, it's a clear sign that the economics of console video games are essentially dead unless you're a HUGE franchise with HUGE invetment (Halo, GTA, MGS) in which case you'll merely earn less money than last gen, or you're on Wii, where you may still lose useful money, but at least the losses will be manageable.
I highly doubt the number is 1 million. Some games like "Deal or No Deal" on the Wii are most likely not very difficult to make and therefore don't cost a lot of money to develop. So the magic number may be a lot lower. Other games like SSBB may need 1 million or a bit less to make some profit. There are variables to consider.
Here's the thing, read the article, THE GUY NEVER EVEN QUOTES REGGIE. There are no quotation marks used when mentioning Reggie. Technically there was no quote. Not to mention the article has obvious factual errors. "Downloadable games on Wii/PS3/360 cost $10". This story was poorly sourced, lacked proper reference and the guy can't even handle a simple quotation. It just goes to show how far the NYT has fallen. They are getting worse than Fox News.
So he was misquoted. Worry = gone 🙂
"When a doofus says a developer needs to sell X number of games on the Wii to be profitable, I all laugh accordingly. However, when Reggie says developers need to sell 1 million copies, on the record, in an interview with the New York Times, I first scratch my head and pray that this is not accurate, for it has dire implications for the entire video game community."
…
…
…
…
I certainly hope not.
"They are getting worse than Fox News."
OT, I'm seriously getting tired of lines like this. I don't really care about Fox News one way or the other, but anyone who thinks they are more biased than the other big 2 cable news networks are extremely naive.