Congrats, Blake. You inspired me this morning with your impromptu poll about Nintendo’s next console and when it might arrive.
I took the poll, but here’s my guess, fleshed out all hyperbole and speculation-like: The next Nintendo console could arrive in late 2010, but an early 2011 arrival is more likely. It will be called the 3DS.
It Must Surprise Them
The linchpin here, as it always has been with Nintendo, is that any new hardware must “surprise” audiences.
True, Iwata and Miyamoto say the word “surprise” in their interviews about as often as a teenage Xbox Live user uses a homophobic slur (i.e. a lot), but if you look at their history, the usage really does mean something with them.
Rumble, motion controls, IR pointers for menu navigation, retro revivals of the highest caliber, directional pads in an era when joysticks were considered the manlier option, the original Wii Sports—all these are moves that genuinely surprised audiences and translated into incredible sales, long lines and a frothing, near-rabid press corps.
Simply tacking on a motion-sensing, augmented reality camera and HD to their next console would do none of these things. It would be inherently un-present day Nintendo-like behavior. It would be the real GameCube 2.0. It would fail.
But let’s revisit what I just said above: long lines, enthusiastic press reception; Arthur C. Clarke technology that requires no glasses and is nigh imperceptible from magic; disrupts the still developing 3D landscape; takes gaming in a direction no one was expecting; genuinely surprises those who play it. Hell, there’s even a fracking countdown clock.
All this and more has been attributed to the 3DS over the past few months. Not the Wii. Not some rumored next gen console being hammered together as a panicked response to competitors’ new motion control technology. Not some HD update that is never going to come. Not from the Move or Kinect, which have managed hardly more than a yawn from consumers, if the latest spending surveys are to be believed. Nope. All this was for the diminutive 3DS.
And really, how could Nintendo seriously surprise the world with another console, without appearing to copy the bulbous, augmented reality-boosting PlayStation Move or arm-flappingly expensive Kinect? In the console space, at the moment, there simply isn’t any technology available that would truly surprise anyone.
So, what then? What’s next?
I ask that, and I keep coming back to the 3DS. This is Nintendo’s next true “console” and it will be the one that receives the bulk of their attention for at least the next three years (starting in 2011).
You want to truly disrupt? You really want to zig while the competition zags battles it out for the scraps of the motion control heap that you created?
If you’re Nintendo, the truly disruptive option in this scenario is to “leave” the console space and focus on the new “portable, glasses-free 3D gaming experience” you single-handedly just created at E3. This isn’t to say Nintendo simply deletes the Wii from its database, which would be idiotic to do or, as an observer, to speculate Nintendo would do.
No, the Wii will continue on, priced to sell and supported by first party titles that would not do well on a portable system (even one so powerfully spec’d as the 3DS). There will probably be new colors, new bundles, a fully integrated MotionPlus Wiimote, and maybe a price cut down the road. It would be just as the DS had done when the Wii launched in 2006, only reversed.
Why, maybe Nintendo will even start to get serious about the oft-neglected Wii-to-DS connectivity we once heard so much about. Wouldn’t that be something?
Dual screen deja vu
Now, to an extent this dynamic already exists. The DS platform is one of the most successful, well-supported pieces of video game hardware ever created. Its install base is larger than the Wii, and Nintendo’s portable brand is, in ever sense of the word, unstoppable. Challengers with more powerful hardware and more initial developer support lie in its wake like discarded toys. Dominance is assured, and the long lines and launch title speculation for the 3DS all but guarantee it will continue at least into the mid-2010’s. The nearest competitor is an already irrelevant, still vaporware PSP phone, and those big, fluffy red meat numbers about iPods and iOS devices that Apple loves to use to incite the fanboys are just that—red meat and fluff.
From the early days of the Wii (Née Revolution), Nintendo has been incredibly open about its plans for disruption. Low cost consoles, less powerful processors, blue oceans and all that—all of these things are open secrets, with disrupting and “saving” the industry being chief amongst them the entire time. What Nintendo said it would do in press conferences back in 2005 and 2006 have literally come to pass. They are not interested in competing with Sony and Microsoft in the gaming space, they are interested in disrupting and burying them.
And, really, what would be more disruptive to the console space than the market leader leaving it altogether to focus entirely on powerful, 3D, hyper-connected portables?
Get ready for it: Nintendo’s next gen console is the 3DS, and it arrives in 2011 for $189.
Wow, did you ever miss the point. Everyone knows the 3DS is coming out. It's not a console, its a portable. Nintendo WILL release another console, the 3DS is NOT it.
Why Fuzz?
Don't forget that in Japan home consoles are in steady decline due to limits on disposable space and time for consumers there. Even the Wii, which is miniscule and makes almost no demands on your time, is not fitting in for a lot of people. If Nintendo wants to hit their maximum potential there, they will have to aim for those customers and that means putting their muscle behind 3DS, not another home console. Will there even be room to launch a new home console while they are doing that?
Not sure what the question is. Why will they release another console? Uhm, becuase anyone with an IQ more than 14 could come up with a bajillion reasons why. That's why.
Then give me one.
Also, you seem to have missed the point of the article. Jack's not trying to tell us that the 3DS is an actually real thing; he's saying that it's going to become Nintendo's spearhead when it comes out. Your rebuttal pretty much amounts to "nuh-uh!" which isn't exactly persuasive. COuld you maybe take some time to formulate an actual rebuttal?
Hrmm, reasons why Nintendo would release another console:
They have the best selling console of all time, they probably want to repeat that
They have always had another console coming
They have openly admitted that they are working on another console
Having a foot in 2 markets is better than one
a portable is NOT a replacement for a home machine
Seriously, do you guys really think Nintendo won't have another console coming?
Obviously Nintendo is going to be advertising the crap outa the 3DS. If the whole point of this post was to say that Nintendo will be showing support for their new portable, I give it a big No sh#t. But they aren't going to get out of the home console business. That's just ridiculous.
@Fuzz:
"If you're Nintendo, the truly disruptive option in this scenario is to “leave†the console space and focus on the new “portable, glasses-free 3D gaming experience†you single-handedly just created at E3. This isn't to say Nintendo simply deletes the Wii from its database, which would be idiotic to do or, as an observer, to speculate Nintendo would do.
No, the Wii will continue on, priced to sell and supported by first party titles that would not do well on a portable system (even one so powerfully spec'd as the 3DS). There will probably be new colors, new bundles, a fully integrated MotionPlus Wiimote, and maybe a price cut down the road. It would be just as the DS had done when the Wii launched in 2006, only reversed."
Your original comment is incredibly ignorant and you obviously skimmed or did not read or understand the gist the post at all.
I'll try to take your points one at a time.
They do want to repeat that, but can they do that with a home console? Who is itching to have their Wii upgraded? Who is asking for a better Wii? If Nintendo releases a new home console they risk overshooting like Sony and Microsoft.
I'm not saying that there isn't any R&D going on for possible future home consoles or that there never will be another one. The question is whether they have any immediate plans for one, or if we are still several years off from a new one. If Nintendo continues to introduce new value propositions on the Wii (like they did with Wii Fit and Motion Plus and seem to be preparing for with the Vitality Sensor) then a new console before they have exhausted those possibilities may simply be a waste of time and money.
Nintendo scraps more than it ships, and sometimes hardware is in development for a long time before it ships. For example, they were basically ready to release a larger DS when the Lite hardware was recently released, but shelved the project in order to focus their manufacturing on meeting demand for the Wii. If the 3DS really takes off, even a home console planned for 2012 will probably have to be put aside until demand can be satisfied.
What 2 markets? Except for the Wii home consoles are in steady decline, and no one has succeeded in convincing the majority of PS2 owners to get a current generation system. It's stupid to keep one of your feet on a sinking ship when the other is on a new continent.
And a portable can and does replace a home console in Japan, where commuters simply don't have the time or space anymore for a home console. If that's the case then they can be best served by putting the best console possible console right in their hands.
This doesn't just mean a lot of advertising and marketing. It means putting the 1st string developers on the software for that system. In the past the really big games have all been on home consoles while portables have received simpler games made by second-string devs. I think with the 3DS we are going to see the reverse of that.
I honestly think the 3ds is coming out this year. Everyone calls me crazy but look at the history. I believe the ds pricing and release date was announced in september of 2004, the same year it released. Same for the wii. The pricing of it and release date was announced in september of 06 and relelased in november. Nintendo is going to announce full details about the 3ds on september 29th therefore the 3ds is coming out this year! Most likely a late november release date around the 4 year anniversery of the wii! Why would they lower the ds price so early in advance if the 3ds is coming out in 2011?
Sorry, Jack, but their is being disruptive, and their is being suicidal. To exit the home console business by not producing a new generation would be suicide to Nintendo. With the expansion in portable gaming to phones, putting all of their eggs in the portable basket isn't going to cut it. You think in 10 years they will still be selling the Wii and have no new console?
No one said ten years. Just not the "5 year cycle" everyone seems to think is an immutable fact of nature. So what about a new Wii in 2015? That's still longer than any console maker has gone without releasing a new iteration of their home line without leaving the business altogether.
And no one said "all their eggs" either. Just that portable would become the main focus, which is something else no one has ever really done before.
I think the 3DS will be released by Christmas, but I don't know. Oh well, only twenty days until we know for sure!
shMerker is making a hell of a lot of sense right now. Who said 10 years? If anything I'll concede three years, having said this:
"This is Nintendo's next true “console†and it will be the one that receives the bulk of their attention for at least the next three years (starting in 2011)."
Nintendo will make a new console (note I do not say "Wii") when it makes financial sense to do so. Right now or the near future ain't it.
But a new portable, with the weight of what's traditionally seen as "console development" behind it, and done so in a way that completely deflates the competition's fixation on consoles, 3D and motion controls? That time is now, and the 3DS will be Nintendo's "console" going forward for the indefinite future.
I'm also inclined to think that Nintendo needs to focus on portables only from now on.
Look at what's going on with Apple's iPad. People are more willing to replace their big boxes with a portable solution, even if that solution is "limited", than everybody first thought.
But now Nintendo as to fight it with Apple (Even if the numbers are not there yet, I don't want to enter that debate). In the last 12 months, DS gamers (and many non-gamers) in my environment have migrated to iOS. Yes, quality and depth of Apps/games varies a lot, but things are moving fast. You can presently find clones of games like Halo/Diablo/GTA/Mario Kart/etc. with Wii quality graphics on iPad and Epic just came on board last week with their Unreal Engine.
The big N will need to bring something new and fresh to the game, to capture our attention back… And, they will need to rethink their game's price point (vs Apps).
Well, Jack, now you are changing your position? Now its just a longer cycle?
In case you didn't read what you wrote,
"And, really, what would be more disruptive to the console space than the market leader leaving it altogether to focus entirely on powerful, 3D, hyper-connected portables?"
Sorry, but if I 'm discussing against an ever-changing position, I may as well just go have a conversation with my Wife.
If you are going to pick a controversial argument, at least stand by it. Sheesh. Blake, can you get some real writers to publish posts?
I don't really think the iPad competes with the DS that much. It starts at around three times the cost. Even if the games are cheap or free you can still get a DS and several games for the price of an iPad. Also the 3DS is still small enough to basically fit in your pocket, whereas the iPad still needs a bag or something if you're going to carry it around.
Finally there's an issue of content. Apple isn't producing any games of their own. Nintendo has an advantage in selling a game machine in that they aren't dependent on anyone else to make games. This is more obviously true now than ever, with the Wii trucking along in first place despite poor 3rd party support. And the 3DS doesn't even have that problem.
Here's a weird thought: What if the 3DS is about recapturing lost PS2 gamers? There's around 60 million people that had a PS2 that haven't bought a new console since then. Maybe Nintendo is gambling that they all grew up, got jobs, and just didn't have the time for gaming any more and thinking a handheld will be able to bring back that desire for them. Think about the software line-up they have coming. Star Fox 64 and Ocarina of time are two of their most popular games with the gamers that would have had an N64 as kids and then a PS2 as teens. Also there's Metal Gear Solid 3, which was a hit on the PS2.
I could see this maybe being about capturing a new swath of lapsed gamers, much as the Wii has for NES and SNES gamers who were left in the cold by 3D consoles.
Not much else really fits into that narrative though, so maybe I'm just smoking crack on this one.
Fuzz, the thesis was "Nintendo's next main console is a handheld, specifically the 3DS." Next does not necessarily mean last.
I don't expect you to argue with two positions when you can't even handle the one that's been in every comment agreeing with the original post, that being that the 3DS will see an unprecedented development effort from Nintendo, to the point of putting home console development on the back burner.
@shMerker "What 2 markets? Except for the Wii home consoles are in steady decline, and no one has succeeded in convincing the majority of PS2 owners to get a current generation system."
That's not true. If you compare the number of consoles sold using the same life to date window, the Wii has outsold the PS2, at least in the US.
@babble "The big N will need to bring something new and fresh to the game, to capture our attention back… And, they will need to rethink their game's price point (vs Apps)."
Nintendo and it's third parties *can't* realistically compete with App pricing, not while still producing the same sorts of games that they have been. Apps are micro-games, the development costs are far lower. The issue is still that there's no way to compete with micro-games when the bulk of your potential audience doesn't actually care about gaming. Apple, and Android, and Flash, and Facebook, will end up destroying everything else simply because they're more accessible, cheaper, and harder to screw up than everything else. The more advanced, sophisticated, expensive, market simply can't survive in the face of the cheaper more profitable one. Nintendo realized this, and started moving to more broadly accessible games, but Apple and Facebook accidentally leap frogged over them, and demonstrated a simple but inescapable truth for the games market; there is no mass market need to fill for complex experiences, only a dwindling increasingly impossible to satisfy niche.
I was staying out of this, not for any real reason, but Fuzz, your condescending tone is outrageous. You started out your statements and arguments with little more than "Nuh-uh, Poo-Poo face!" and have gotten downright disrespectful to the writer, and others, since then.
So I will put my $0.02 cents in…
Fuzz, so YOU can read what he wrote, the whole thing, (not just part of a sentence from one paragraph in a single part of the article) even though it was posted above, let me re-post it now:
"So, what then? What's next?
I ask that, and I keep coming back to the 3DS. This is Nintendo's next true “console†and it will be the one that receives the bulk of their attention for at least the next three years (starting in 2011).
You want to truly disrupt? You really want to zig while the competition zags battles it out for the scraps of the motion control heap that you created?
If you're Nintendo, the truly disruptive option in this scenario is to “leave†the console space and focus on the new “portable, glasses-free 3D gaming experience†you single-handedly just created at E3. This isn't to say Nintendo simply deletes the Wii from its database, which would be idiotic to do or, as an observer, to speculate Nintendo would do.
No, the Wii will continue on, priced to sell and supported by first party titles that would not do well on a portable system (even one so powerfully spec'd as the 3DS). There will probably be new colors, new bundles, a fully integrated MotionPlus Wiimote, and maybe a price cut down the road. It would be just as the DS had done when the Wii launched in 2006, only reversed.
Why, maybe Nintendo will even start to get serious about the oft-neglected Wii-to-DS connectivity we once heard so much about. Wouldn't that be something?"
I did this because to understand any of the early or initial statements, you have to read the whole thing. You also see how, near the beginning, IN THE PART YOU QUOTED, he put quotations around the word leave? That is commonly used, in writing, to imply only a partial (by definition) use of the word as normally used or understood, and that is exactly what he did. He used the term leave as in, to no longer focus primarily on the console over the handheld, and actually do the reverse.
Two closing notes on my "tirade" against you:
1) There is no need bring up (ESPECIALLY in an insulting, disrespectful, and condescending manner) your wife, even for the sake of your argument.
2) If/when you think you have a valid point in the future (should that ever be the case) show your position in a respectful and serious manner and, who knows, you might be able to not only make people agree with you, but prove you aren't the ignorant prick you come off as.
RisnDevil
I said not counting the Wii. It's in the part you quoted even. Anyway the rest of your post is about how console gaming is in decline so I don't really see what your point is.
"I don't really think the iPad competes with the DS that much"
Same here, but iPod does. I was only talking about my own gaming experience on iPad. And I was kinda placing the iPad vs Wii/Console…
"What if the 3DS is about recapturing lost PS2 gamers?"
Again, those gamers (older with more income) are probably on iPad now… Just like most young ones around me, who were on DS not so long ago, all bought iPod Touchs (with their own money!?) in the last 12 months.
This 3DS needs to be great, slick and not look like a toy. Nintendo can't do a two steps release this time around (like DS phat, then DS Lite. Or GBA, then GBA SP).
@Eolirin "Apps are micro-games, the development costs are far lower."
Apps are not all micro-games (yes, most are atm).
But, more and more big names (Industry shift) are coming along with equivalent or better games. One good example is Civilization Revolution: 30$+ on DS vs 10$ on iPad. 100x more enjoyable and complete than the DS version (I have both). I know, I can't compare apple and oranges, but I am. : )
@Babble, has anyone described their thought process to you on replacing a DS with an iPod touch? This is a development I don't see in my own environment, so I'm curious what's going on there.
@Fuzz: And If I wanted to have an argument with someone who cherry picked facts to fit their skewed reality and who continuously chose to put words in the mouth of the people they're arguing with, I'd take up religion and go to church. No thanks, and you obviously have still not read the post or understood it yet. But there's still time!
And just curious, but my professional life on the Internet, with gaming and tech writing is pretty much an open book. What is it that you do? If your appeal to Blake is some kind of passive, insecure job inquiry, perhaps you should just move along, because it reeks of the snarky, predictable "I can say anything because I'm anonymous" bullshit that's polluted the system for pretty much forever now.
Nice talk about your wife too, by the way. Is her name Subservient Chicken?
Actually @babble, I don't really get the thrust of your argument. On the one hand you're saying that dedicated game consoles are going to fall by the wayside because they don't offer the simpler, more accessible experience of iOS devices, but then you say the iPad is attractive because it has a more full-featured version of a DS game. Which is it?
I think he's saying the iPad game offers more than the DS, less than the console/PC, is cheaper, and portable. Basically what the 3DS might help address (content primarily, by being strong enough to push more of it).
I have no interest in writing for Infendo, but if I did, I'd stick by my argument. Yes, I read your whole post. You claim to say that Nintendo's next "main console" is the 3DS. I still don't see what your point is. Are you saying that Nintendo will give up on the home console? Becuase your concluding sentaces seam to indicate that. If that's not what you are tring to say, than I can only assume you mean Nintendo will market the crap outa their new portable, and make it front and center. Well no duh. Of course they will, unless they want it to be another PSPgo. But Nintendo aren't that dumb.
So unless you are taking the position that Nintendo is not going to produce a new home console (which at this point in the discussion, you really haven't made clear), then you are just stating obvious points, and their is really no point ot the whole post.
My comment to Blake is that considering this post, the and the terrible Metroid "review", he may want to consider reviewing the articles before they get posted, if he isn't already doing so. I've been around here along time, so I'm not trying to hide behind any anonymity here.
As for the wife joke, apparently you guys haven't heard the saying "it's a woman's prerogative to change her mind", which is what I was referring too. She would laugh if I showed that to her, since she has a sense of humour.
@shMerker "has anyone described their thought process to you on replacing a DS with an iPod touch?"
Mmm, no. We are talking about kids here. I was seeing them play with DS for the last 3-4 years, and now in the last year, they almost all have iPods instead.
@shMerker "I don't really get the thrust of your argument […] Which is it?"
Both and none? I've never said fall, wayside or even talked about the "simpler, more accessible experience of iOS devices". I was only saying :
– The big N needs to/will follow the market trend and go full portable;
– They now have to compete directly with iOS devices;
– The 3DS will need to be strong/sleek/magical (lol) to gain attention back from customers who have "grown" from the DS.
I'm not looking for a fight, I'm just discussing about what I see happening in my part of the world. : )
@babble My mistake, it was Eolirin who was talking about Nintendo needing to aim for something simpler.
One thing about the supposed trend away from dedicated gaming devices is that someone or other has been saying that that was happening since the 80s. That isn't to say that it won't happen, just that apparently the conditions for such a shift have never been right up to this point, despite a lot of people thinking it was the case at many times.
"Protable" like the GameCube??
Fuzz is lame. =P
I completely understand your point, Jack. You're an excellent writer. =)
Great article, Jack. And, as always, I'm with shMerker.
Okay, here comes my point inall this. Nintendo WILL release a new console people! You think the Wii is it? No way in hell. Nintendo can not afford to not make another console. The 3DS is not a console, it is a portable.
I have been listening to podcasts, infendo radio included, for a long time. One podcast I listened to suggested that it could be that Nintendo will release a Wii Deluxe system. Meaning not a full on successor to Wii, but a half step as you will to a new "Revolutionary" console. One that may include HD visuals and better wifi. Why would Nintendo do this? The next true idea they may have in mind is not ready yet to be fully put into motion. An example of this might be holographic gameplay. I truly feel that is the next big thing just like Motion controls were. We are headed in that direction, like it or not. Nintendo will not be satisfied with this half step Wii Deluxe, but they will have to put it out there because everyone expects them to. Nintendo can not affor d to ignore their fanbase. The people who have stuck by them for 25 plus years of gaming greatness, yours truly included.
To conclude, just like the #DS offers #D without glasses, what if Nintendo released a new console that had its own 3D LCD glasses free experience? No, I am not talking about Virtual BOY, but like a 3D TV built into the console that could sync with the 3DS?
I doubt this is going to be a part of the 3DS but at some point handhelds will be able to push enough resolution to display on TV. Why couldn't one of the next "consoles" be both portable and playable via TV.
Those who mentioned Nintendo responding to the eventual Sony PS3 successor reminded me that the 360 has already been on the market for 5 years, and since we can be pretty sure the next Xbox isn't coming out in 2010, this will be the first time in the history of gaming that there's been a span of five years within which no new TV-based consoles were introduced.
The gaming industry has changed, and is going to change more. Whether it follows the PC industry and shifts more or more to portable devices, or becomes more and more bound to add-on accessories like Wii Fit, Move and Kinect where such accessories have failed time and again in the past, or something completely different will happen, I don't know. But I'll stick with 2012 as my prediction for the Wii's successor, as opposed to the successor to the DS.
I have owned and used a DS for at least three years now. I just played Dragon Quest IX for over a hundred hours and loved every minute. I would keep playing if it were not for my son wanting to have his shot. I have started playing Fire Emblem Blazing Swords in Hector hard mode. All this to say…
I bought an ipod Touch a month ago. I use it daily to play music and I already have my favourite apps. I have downloaded seven games, four of which never received a second play. The other three are great (short) time wasters (solitare, mahjong, etc.).
I was born in the 60's and I have seen gaming from the start. I still have my Collecovision and NES and have come back into gaming with the Wii and DS. I have no desire to buy another Wii (unless it replaces the one I have as I and my family are wearing it out).
When and if Nintendo comes out with something new and exciting I will consider it.
Oh wait. They do have something new and exciting coming out. The 3DS. I am totally looking forward to it and I hope it comes out before Christmas. I definitely won't be waiting for it to show up under the tree.
Besides, Donkey Kong Country will make a fine stocking stuffer.
I would be cool with the 3DS being Nintendos next console… if I could hook it up to my TV and plug my arcade and gamecube controllers into it. I will miss not having all those control options. Street Fighter deserves an arcade stick.
In the gameinformer magazine they said nintendo will release the wii-ds or a combination of the two so it is going to be a wii but more compact and with the ds dual screens and bottom touch screen
Are we referring to The Indigo Lunchbox here? 😉
Because that boy had a handle and I have to say that it was DEFINITELY the most portable and strangest of all Nintendo consoles.
I freaking love that handle. 3ds has got nothing on that handle.
Man, people on the internet have to many opinions that should be kept to themselves… Everyone's thinks that just because they have a thought in their head they should say it… Rolls eyes. —– Yes I'm talking about myself also as I would have not posted otherwise.