Intelligent passion for all things NintendoNew to Infendo? Start here ↗
← Back to the journal
Infendo / An independent perspective

Bleszinski’s bro: Oh noes! No more hardcore!

I spent a few minutes today trying to figure out what Tyler Bleszinski was trying to say in his guest column for Newsweek. Something about the Wii’s success killing hardcore gaming. Even now, I’m not so sure I know what the heck I just read. Hardcore gamers are led Zeppelin? The rest of us are […]

Hardcore gamersI spent a few minutes today trying to figure out what Tyler Bleszinski was trying to say in his guest column for Newsweek. Something about the Wii’s success killing hardcore gaming. Even now, I’m not so sure I know what the heck I just read. Hardcore gamers are led Zeppelin? The rest of us are the Bee Gee’s?

First, it was that he was disgusted that grandmas were buying Wii games and that publishers were on the precipice of this casual gaming chasm, ready to jump in headfirst. But then he assured us that he knows hardcore games aren’t going away. Then Wii Sports was a tech demo and everyone is going to stop what they’re doing and make copies of it My head is spinning, but I think I know what the problem might be.Cliffy’s bro appears to be worried that hardcore gamers will become niche as publishers recognize the success of low tech, pick up and play Wii games. Guess what, they are already! In fact, they always have been. It’s my belief that hardcore gamers have become so insulated from the rest of society that they forgot how small their little island really was. When someone surrounds them self with only like-minded people, it becomes quite a culture shock — almost unbelievable — to them that they might actually be the group that’s not really driving the bus. B’s Bro even says as much in his column:

My problem is what this new crowd appears to be drawn to. Games like Wii Sports, Wii Play and Cooking Mama have become some of the biggest sellers, and that is what has me worried. If these are the type of games that become blockbusters, then you can count on other gaming companies who cater to the more hardcore gamer–aka me and the milions of others who’ve been driving this business–to promptly change direction

Tyler, the only reason you were driving the business in the last generation is because you guys were the only ones playing. That’s great for you, but there are ten times as many people out there who want something else. Ten times as many people who also grew up with video games (like me) who didn’t drink the “gaming is for young males only” Kool-Aid and stopped playing games around the time of the PS2. And when I say something else, I’m not talking mini games (Wario wears thin very quickly, I admit); I’m talking anything but the “meaty” fare Bleszinski describes in his column. People just got tired of trying to get into the gamer gentleman’s club, and who could blame them.

And I don’t really understand this point about fearing casual gamers. It’s a pretty vague term with little meaning a far as I’m concerned, but columns like this go a long way in framing it and making it sound like a negative label. When I think casual gamers, I think “those who are not hardcore gamers.” I don’t automatically assume they are grandmas and kiddies and girls, as Bleszinski does. As the years progress and Wii continues to sell, yes, there will be a monumental shift in how games are designed. However, there’s no indication a lion’s share of the development will be shifted to mini games, or cooking games, or anything.

For proof, look to the DS. It sold 650,000 units last month in Japan (or the US I can’t remember). The system is also very “casual gamer” friendly, and yet, the library remains diverse. I realize portables and consoles are apples and oranges, but there are parallels that exist.

But the times, they are a-changing. If Nintendo has its way, young males will no longer be the dominant segment of the console audience–and this transition appears to be happening faster than I expected.

Oh no, big bad Nintendo is taking gaming away from young males. The apocalypse is surely upon us. What ever will we do if young male gamers (young, male, American gamers) no longer rule the roost? Hopefully, we’ll see something new hit the fan. Maybe we’ll see something without a gun. I’m not against guns in games by any means, but when a console’s entire software library appears to depend on them for success, there’s a problem.

Hardcore gamers like the Bleszinskis probably attack and shun games like Wii Sports for all the same reasons people throughout history have shunned and attacked things: they either don’t understand them, or they fear them. The column sounds like a little of both. Hardcore gamers were but a small segment of a pie who’s main layer — everyone else but them — was made dormant by the fact that hardcore gamers are by and large attracted to a certain type of video games. It’s that dormant, much larger, piece of the pie that I’m interested in, because it reeks of innovation and games no one’s even thought of yet. And the fact that Bleszinski seems to think this untapped resource will only buy up mini games betrays far more ignorance than I would have expected from someone in games design (he mentions the term mini games several times throughout).

Where I think there is a distinct lack of innovation is in the games that the column cites as a godsend to the PS3 and 360: Games like Motorstorm and Resistance and Gears of War. These games all sold in spades at first, but will we be talking about them next year? Probably not. Not until the GoW sequels hit, of course. These games were all a flash in the pan — big bucks and marketing up front, nothing in the rear — and were wildly successful with the crowd they were intended for, and no one else. That’s a great trend for a fan club, but not for a business model.

Hardcore gamers and games won’t go away because of Nintendo, nor do I want them to. They just no longer control the direction of the industry, and that’s a great thing

More to discover.Keep exploring ↗
Infendo community

Join the conversation

26 comments

Share your perspective. Keep it thoughtful, welcoming and on topic.

  1. Wouldn't real hardcore gamers play anything they like? Does it have to be new? No matter how hardcore you are, there are still hundreds, perhaps thousands, of games you never played.

  2. Amen, brother. I've spent the last couple months blazing through a Gamecube library that I hardly knew existed. And my favorite game of all time? X-Com:UFO Defense. NOTHING comes close to besting that one on my list, and its over 10 years old.

  3. I don't give a rats as what Cliffy B thinks about anything, he is totally irrelevant and has said ridiculous things on more than one occasion. Why would I care about his brother's opinion? These people mean nothing, don't give them a chance to think their opinion matters.

  4. i know a lot of people with wiis. i don't know ANY hardcore gamers with wiis. everyone i know is playing wii sports and wario ware and excite truck. all games that lack depth.

    in terms of depth, gears of war vs red steel or any other wii shooter is no contest. how about excite truck v forza 2?

    it's funny to criticize some excellent games on other systems as business models for fan clubs… ever heard of pikimin? or even mario for that matter? super mario sunshine was also wildly successful with its crowd, and the wii-sporters i know couldn't care less about it.

    for years, the games industry has been catering more and more to casual games. and now the wii is the system of causal gamers (right behind cell phones and pc solitaire).

    Tyler isn't arguing for a viable business model. He's saying the obvious: more casual games might leave less of the development pie for hardcore games. So unless the pie size changes, that's bad for us who want depth.

  5. deepthought, I somewhat disagree, but will keep the pie analogy intact.

    The pie was controlled mostly by hardcore gamers, and now it is not. Depth in gaming will still exist, seeing as there are millions of people who want it, but it will no longer be the driving force it once was.

    Then again, who's to say these so-called casual gamers don't want depth too? Just because it's not Cliffy's bro's idea of depth doesn't mean its going to be bunk. For such a cartoony game, Animal Crossing sure has a lot of depth, right?

  6. Wasn't there some poll or something that showed that a lot of people over 50 play games online? Be it simple Flash games, they are games nonetheless.
    Just because more people who don't want to play so called 'hardcore games' play games on consoles, doesn't mean we'll get less 'hardcore games'. There is still that group of hardcore gamers that buy the games. The market is simply expanding. Bigger groups of different types of gamers, more games.

    I don't see a problem. Maybe more hardcore gamers will want a game they can just pick up and play for a while per day (instead of the hours of WoW a day), maybe new older gamers who are just getting into console games (again) will get into 'hardcore' games.

  7. It's funny watching the dinosaurs of the industry trying to forcibly evolve to survive the asteroid collision that is Wii. Destructoid is a good place to watch the species dying. The hardcore, VOCAL minority gets lots of attention on the internet, but they just don't underdstand that they are a small fraction of the total, potential game-playing population.

    Nintendo has said that they are an AND company. Casual AND hardcore games. The traditional games are coming, they just take longer to develop than minigame collections. While EA and Ubisoft may jump on the minigame bandwagon at the expense of big-budget "cinematic experiences," what big loss is that? And Bioware and Epic and Factor 5 and Blizzard will still create those epic games IF the market demands them. So, Tyler B, instead of whining about casual gamers, put your money where your mouth is. The market goes where the money is. Vote with your wallet.

    Wii is the hardcore whipping boy. Wii's success is the perfect target for hardcore fanboys to blame for everything that is going wrong with the industry. They don't realize that these problems would still exist without Wii. If Nintendo dropped out of the console race, and the Wii was never released, what would the state of the industry be? PS3 and 360 fighting for the .1% of the population that already plays videogames, and the rest of the world would still be playing Popcap and Yahoo games online. The ridiculous development budgets for "top-tier" games would still be there. The redundant game design and "sequalitis" would still exist. Red Ring of Death would still visit every 5th 360. PS3 sales would still be abysmal. Casual gamers won't destroy the industry. But they just might save it.

    Evolve or die! PS3 and 360 are lumbering dinosaurs. Wii (and DS) are cute, furry little rodents. And "casual" gamers (and thier wallets) are the asteroid.

  8. I just think that guy draws the wrong conclusions:
    Why should game companies developing "hardcore games" for all consoles and even for the PC switch to "casual games" or "mini games"?
    Because of Wii success? Oh come on.

    If there is a high-enough demand for those games, they will be produced.
    And if some companies won't produce those games anymore, even more "hardcore" customers for the others, since they won't switch to RRR or Wii Sports anyway.
    That's Economy 101.

    If there is a reason for less "hardcore content", it may as well be that production costs for cutting-edge games have soared with the "hardcore gamers" always expecting better and more spectacular HD- & HDR-graphics (especially after they bought one of those expensive next-gen consoles), while sales and game prices aren't rising to cover the higher costs.
    Add licencing fees, some illegal copying and maybe a few very similiar games competing for the customer dollar and *poof* there go your profits.

    The solution: concentration, as we saw for years now, even before Wii. Black holes like EA and others suck up all the small and medium sized companies, trashing unprofitable games and discontinuing similiar games, thereby increasing sales of the remaining titles.
    Less choice especially for games that are just bought and played by few.

    Tough Luck for hardcore gamers.

    Good times & lots of new fun games for casual gamers. 🙂

  9. Why is it that we keep pushing this "hardcore vs. casual gamers" concept? There is no such thing! If you look at the market, you will see both "hardcore" and "casual" games popping up in the shelves, and in many cases both kinds being picked up by the same gamer (I, for one, like 'em both!). The "hardcore" and "casual" labels only represent the amount of time you dedicate to that particular game…

    We are just witnessing the equivalent of a Cambrian Explosion in the entertainment industry (not just in gaming!), where all kinds of media and games are going to be produced to fit any amount of leisure time and power of concentration and expendable income the consumer might have… One kind might be at the top of the sales charts at any given time, but it won't stay there for long.

  10. I love all the paleontological references in the comments!

    Yeah, I can't make out what this guy's exact thrust is. Does he hate that grandma for not liking the games he likes? He himself says that there will always be hardcore games… so what's the problem? The developers who stay to make hardcore games will get better and better at what they do, and everyone else will make the games that they really want to make as well.

    Seriously, hardcore gamers have to stop over-reacting. Look at the XBox 360! Hardcore gaming isn't going ANYWHERE for a long while. The only difference now is that it'll come with more innovative controls (thanks to Nintendo's push), be less stigmatized (now that more people will have a good feeling towards videogames in general), and it won't be the be-all-and-end-all center-of-the-universe some people like to think it is.

    ~Carmine "Cai" M. Red
    Kairon@aol.com

  11. We all hear about the hardcore vs the casual. Why? They can both exist without "wiping out" one or the other. I, myself, am a mix of the two. I love to play "casual" games 75% of the time and "hardcore" games 25%. Casual games are great when you have a short amount of time to jump into something and play. When I have more time I love to play more intense hardcore games. "Sometimes you feel like a nut, sometimes you don't"-either way it's all good.

    To all those casual gamers, we should be thanking the hardcore game developers for pushing graphics to get them to what they are today. To all those hardcore gamers, we should be thanking the casual game developers for pushing the "fun factor" to where is it today.

    People need to quit arguing and complaining and just get their game on, period.

  12. I don't really need to add anything; Jack and the posters above me have eloquently covered pretty much 90% of what I might've wanted to say.

    That having been said, I'm having an absolute blast watching these self-anointed elitists whip themselves and each other into a tizzy over these sales trends..

  13. why would i even want to be a hard core gamer? as long as nintendo gives me zelda, mario, metroid, smash, i'm content. party games are awesome too

  14. this guy is a bit short sighted. i mean if you're a movie lover and you see a grandma buying tickets to watch happy feet, would that disgust you? come on now. there's many people out in the world that could potentially be a video game player, why can't they play too? because you and your little 15-20 year old boyfriend club don't want to allow it. sounds immature to me. video games are an entertainment medium no different that movies, music, television or books, except that is interactive. there should be content for everyone. what if every movie made was similar to doom starring the rock? you mean there's no room in the world for a titanic? these young boys should grow up and not feel threatened because other people can like games too. its absolutely silly. and you know its not just the game players, its also the developers that are part of this club. something needs to change in the industry, and i'm glad its happening.

  15. and yes i agree with some here. there is a such thing as game genres, but to separate games between casual and hardcore is impossible. is super mario bros a casual or hardcore game? zelda? metroid? tetris? puzzle quest? trauma center? nba live? is it the length of the game? the difficulty? the genre? the blood? the sex? is it the M for mature symbol? the T for teen symbol? the coolness of it? the age of the IP? what is it? only FPS's? only RTS's? only MMO's? what constitutes a hardcore game? what constitutes a casual? i play all types of games so i'm not sure which is which. you get a different answer for any person you ask. this is just silly and a total waste of time. i'm starting to think that people who try to divide games into these 2 categories just don't know much about games. that's my conclusion.

  16. here's another one, so do hardcore game players only play hardcore games? do casual game players only play casual games? so if a hardcore player plays a casual game, does that make the hardcore gamer a casual gamer, and the casual game a hardcore game and vice versa? so what do you call a person that plays all type of games, across all different genres? is he/she a casual or hardcore gamer? i say call this person a gamer that loves gaming for gaming.

  17. Jack, not to completely disagree or anything but when you wrote "…When I think casual gamers, I think “those who are not hardcore gamers"…"

    We need to get the exact definition of 'hardcore gamers'…

    What does it mean to be 'hardcore'. Does it mean that you HAVE to play: WoW (or various PC shooter's/MMO etc…), PS3 and you NEED to play Resistance, 360 and you MUST play or be great at Halo? In my opinion, it just means that you just love to play video games. Who is HARDCORE?

    I am a hardcore gamer, although I do NOT have any of the above. Nor do I intend on playing any of them. I have a Mac laptop, Nintendo Wii, GameCube, SNES, Famicom, DS Lite, GBA SP. I have been into games since my brother and I received a Magnavox Odyssey 300 for Pong, only. (These were the pre-Nintendo days.) In school, once we completed our homework, we could play one of three games on the Apple IIe. Breakout, Oregon Trail or my personal fav, Hard Hat Mack. We pooled our money together to get an NES, and have had at least one system from each of the passed generations including now.

    I am hardcore all the way. Many people have been stating that the Wii is not for the 'hardcore'. I disagree to the fact that, Nintendo is just creating more 'hardcore gamers'. Even if we intend to play a little more casually than some.

  18. I bet this guy thinks the Earth is flat and that women shouldn't have the vote. And what's with those horseless carriages?!

    What a narrow and fixed view of the world. I am a (fairly) young white western male and I can't wait until the day I play a game online and don't get 'pwned like a fag' by a 'hardcore' gamer…maybe I'll meet a lady (he, he) with boobs and everything…

  19. Here here. Im sure hoping that developers start to use their imagination a bit more and come up with originaly games instead of just running, shooting and driving.

  20. So the success of the Wii automatically means that developers won't make those high profile, million selling, cutting edge, genre defining, innovative, 'hardcore' games anymore? No, I think it means the half-arsed developers who turn out generic 'me too' copies and endless 'just another shooter' games will do something else instead. In other words, same cream, less crap.

    However, the success of the Wii does mean that Epic aren't going to be able to make as much money from Unreal Engine 3 since, (1) the most successful console isn't powerful enough to handle it and (2) instead of making generic shooters using their engine, developers are going to be making more casual games.

    All the bleating coming from Epic execs and their entourage is just because they failed to back the winner this gen and it'll probably cost them a pretty penny as a result.

  21. Jared, they're all non-casual games you listed.
    So if Nintendo made fewer Zeldas/Marios/Metroids/Smash (maybe even none at all) as the casual aspect of Wii was so profitable, would you not care?

    @Doughboy, I totally agree! Everybody reading this blog is hardcore by default. It doesn't depend on the depth of the game rather a better measure is how much of your life it takes up…

  22. @ the boy who likes to (and everyone else on infendo)…

    I am also sick of the same "…running, shooting and driving [games]…". Let's get creative.

    We keep stating that Nintendo and the game companies need to just come up with more original/new genres of games. Like what? I have an idea for a post/contest:

    What is your idea for a Nintendo game (Wii, DS or possibly combo of both together)? Let's help out the companies, come up with some ideas for some genres we would like to see.

  23. i liked that movie analogy, so here's another take on tyler's article:

    the movie sweet spot is pg-13. R movies just restrict the audience too much. As a result, movies that SHOULD AND NEED to be R are become craptacular pg-13s. AVP for instance. (who in the world decided that a combination of aliens and predator should be anything other than a hard R??)

    similarly: games. Tyler is worried hardcore games will be, ah-hem, dumbed down to become more accessible to this casual market. And less truly hardcore games will be made (notice i still think he's worried about the decline of hardcore games, not the decline of hardcore gamers).

    this has already happenned. the last few zeldas were laughably easy. Ninja Gaiden Black was SO.OMG.UBER.HARDCORE… but really only by today's standards (still can't believe normal mode on that game was so feared). Gears was really no great challenge on insane difficulty (takes less than a minute to beat that huge spider things from the trailers… wtf?) But I still can't beat the original Ninja Gaiden. I already see games moving towards the lowest common denominator. So maybe it's not unreasonable to worry that hardcore gamers will have less viable choices as the market includes more gamers only interested in casual games.

    oh, and since this is already rambling, here's some ideas on how to classify casual games v hardcore games:
    – how instantly rewarding they are (wii tennis v top spin)
    – how difficult they are (zelda:TP v The Adv of Link)
    – how deep they are (forza2 v excite truck)

  24. Well I'd buy more "hardcore" games for the Wii if, y'know, there were more that I'd like to get (i.e. titles I like, with characters I'd like to "hang out" with, in worlds I'd like to spend time exploring, that isn't buggy, rushed, etc.). Unfortuantely if companies with people like Mark Raine treat the Wii and its gamers as some second rate citizens, and then talking about how they don't want to make (hardcore) games for it (and ironically simplifying the Wii's appeal as a mini-game system — because, y'know, the lack of hardcore games that such companies won't make, duh), then shoot, I guess it must be the Wii's fault.

This discussion is closed to new comments.

Infendo · Play. Listen. Discover.

Your next discovery awaits.

Stay in the loop
Privacy & browser progress

Reading, listening and game progress lasts for this page without preference permission; with permission, this browser remembers for one year. Rating badges follow your saved ratings, independently of that preference. Analytics permission separately controls analytics and CRM reporting. Resetting browser progress does not delete CRM records.

Want to keep your points? Sign in →
Sign in