Blake’s already posted a few thoughts on Nintendo’s dominance of North America today, but I thought I’d cut and paste the first paragraph of Nintendo’s press release on the news, and then reflect on it with unabashed love and admiration.
“Already riding a streak as America’s No. 1 seller of video game consoles, No. 1 seller of portable game systems and No. 1 publisher of video games, Nintendo added more chips to its pile in April ’ with not just one, but the country’s four best-selling games.”
No.1, No. 1, No. 1. Who could have imagined a year ago, even seven months ago in the days before the release of the Wii, that Nintendo — lowly third place and otherwise defeated Nintendo — would be in such a position; a position that could soon allow them to drive the direction of the entire industry? Regardless of your personal opinion of Nintendo and corporations at large, the company took a huge risk with the Wii and thus far it has paid off in spades. You have to give them a little respect for that. A head nod at least.
Yeah, this makes me all giddy. It's like when your favorite sports team has a winning season. Having graduated a design major, I love seeing great design and ideas win out. That's how it should be. While Sony and Microsoft are watching the speedometer, Nintendo is watching the road.
Actually… they didn't
In business, one way of quantifying risk is by multiplying the probability of failure by the amount of money that would be lost by failure.
It's very clear that by making a profit at just about every step, while there was at least a moderate probability of failing to sell, there was essentially zero chance of losing money, and hence no real risk in the experiment. Of course there is the time value of money, as in the resources they committed could potentially be better spent elsewhere, but the reality is Nintendo made by far the least risky and most practical system.
Compare this to Xbox360 ($120 nominal loss per unit at release) and PS3 ($240 nominal loss per unit at release). Fine, PS3 was at least perceived to have a very low chance of sales failure, but Low Chance X High Stakes is still more than High Chance X No Stakes.
Further, everyone talks about how their direction was a gamble, and it certainly was unusual. But consider the alternatives:
a) Go third party (and certainly make less money)
b) Make yet another high stakes machine competing at the same level for 3rd parties who didn't give them the time of day when they did have the most powerful system available. (and almost certainly make less money)
I'd say from Nintendo's perspective, the decisions were obvious.
"While Sony and Microsoft are watching the speedometer, Nintendo is watching the road"
That's GOLD, ChrisB, GOLD!
And elmer brought up a very good point of Nintendo having been the manufacturer that took the least risk. I think Jack really means they throught up the most inventive and attractive solution, like a Mathematical genius! I wouldn't say the solution was "obvious", but there definitely was only one way to go for Nintendo, and they came up with the right solution!
I'm sorry, but basing the success of a system on a motion control wand, and not specs — in this day and age of horsepower over brains — is not a risk?
Nintendo very much took a risk with the Wii and the DS. It was a strategic and very educated risk, but it was a risk none-the-less. And to make a profit, people must want to buy your system. Just because Nintendo factored in a profit on each system into their strategy, rather than be a loss leader, doesn't somehow negate the fact that selling the Wii was a risk. The argument fails the logic test because it somehow assumes a company that profits from each unit sold is somehow not taking a risk by selling it.
And there are plenty of great articles out there why Nintendo could never go third party (like Sega). Their software development is so ingrained with their hardware that separating the two would kill them both and leave the company with nothing. Option B was DOA at Nintendo, IMO, so that leaves them one one choice: take a gamble, zig while the industry zags, and risk it all. There was never any time when the Wii's success was guaranteed — indeed many "journalists and experts" and third party developers (EA, anyone?) had already written Nintendo off in 2006 — so I fail to see how selling it was *not* a risk.
@ Jack
Basing your business on making money on every product is not a risk. From the business perpective there was no financial risk because there was basically no way they could lose money. There was also little market share for them to lose. And it's not just a wand control; the affordable price in the face of extortionate competition certainly has played a role. Responsible consumers care about money just as responsible businesses do.
Even under the worst case scenario they would sell 5 million units in the generation at the barest minimum, simply off the back of the Nintendo name. Even that would be a massive reduction from the 15-20 million or so devout Nintendo followers from the last generation. And yet with only 5 million units they would make perfectly sustainable profits. If their system lost $100 per unit at launch and they never sold the kind of numbers to achieve economies of scale that reduce cost faster than price, then they might lose billions of dollars. Which would kill them. That is risk. In a business sense.
Ok, I simplified things a little. Sure there are overheads in development, launch, unsold stock etc, so that if they sold 1000 Wiis in its lifetime (like Gizmondo) then they would lose money. But not much. And that wasn't going to happen.
Like I said, alternative A wasn't really an attractive option, since as you say (and I agree) Nintendo's success has always relied on a symbiosis between hardware and software that they cooperatively direct.
As I implied, option B, having been attempted with Gamecube, would have failed and they knew it.
Essentially, they could mimic the competition, they could differentiate from the competition, or they could give up. The choice was obvious.
Besides, if you were running a business, how would you weigh up risk?
Probability X Loss is entirely reasonable
elmer, instead of trying to think logically, you should open your eyes and ears to reality.
the media and many gamers were calling nintendo the loser as soon as they heard it was motion sensative, and nintendo even felt that if they didnt sell more then the gamecube that they would question their purpose as a hardware manufacturer, or something like that.
all sides had doubts about how this "risk" would pay off. sure they make a profit off of the system, and license off games, but what if they do only sell even 20 million systems, but then games barely sell
even so, there isnt just the cost of making the games and system, there is marketing, research, partnerships they pay to support, and salary of people besides developers/producers, like does iwatas pay get fit into every single budget, or averaged? do bonuses get put in?
it is a risk if it isnt guaranteed to get them to a point of sure long term profit. of course, now we are seeing that the worst way to do so was to go down the same path, but 1-2 years ago, listen to how everybody thought the system would do, and you tell me how many people besides you didnt think it was risky? if nintendo said at that time that they wouldnt be happy with just 20mil sold, i think even they were nervous they may actually do that little, and i a happy they took that chance which paid off. it looks so far like they have every chance of beating there last gen efforts hands down.
Yes, I totally remember and was totally pissed off with the way every last developer, industry journalist, non-industry journalist, publisher, retailer, analyst and fanboy totally wrote off Nintendo in the face of 'obvious' Sony superiority. Motion controls? SILLY! The only way forward has always been graphics! Systems have always been sold at considerable loss! … Retards. As late as August 2006 analysts were predicting 3 million Wiis sold by 2008. Why? Because kids (and therefore 'kids' systems') aren't cuel. And predicting things that haven't happened before isn't their strong suit.
The point is that it doesn't matter what everyone else was saying, because everyone else was wrong. The only reason Nintendo EVER questioned themselves was because every member of the $8 billion industry told them they were wrong. Much like focus groups telling Nintendo that Mario Bros was a shitty waste of their time and should never be sold. If you believed the general perception of the last generation then Xbox nearly did as well as PS2, while Nintendo was on the verge of death. In fact only two companies made more money from games than Nintendo, and neither of them were Microsoft.
Nintendo have tapped into the real consumer (ordinary people, who buy games system for entertainment and expect fun they can get into for reasonable money). They thought it in 2005 and the knew it in 2006.
Basically Nintendo were right (I'd say fairly obviously), everyone else was wrong (also fairly obviously). What makes it all the more retarded is that Nintendo showed everyone this with the DS, and everyone still failed to learn their lesson with Wii. Can you believe half the developers STILL aren't sold on Wii? Capcom has yet to release a Wii game. Capcom for Christ's sake.
Fine, motion controls may have been a little bit non-obvious (although I'd contend that improving the human machine interfaces for interactive media in fact IS obvious). But making something affordable, profitable and easy for new unfamiliar markets to use definitely is obvious!
I'll have you know Nintendo is famous for having very very few employees (sub 5000 for a company with billions in liquid assets) and no debts. After the Mario debacle they don't have much love for market researchers. Did you know that Apple, the company rated as having the best brand in the world, spends absolutely zero money on professional marketing? Have you noticed the parallels between the two?
As for profits, had the Wii sold only 1 million consoles 'till now (a failure by most sales measures), it's likely they would have still broken even on launch activities. Had they sold zero then they wouldn't have lost a fortune in any case. They've exceeded 7 million. I don't know what their R&D costs were, but I'm willing to bet that by adapting GC hardware they were minimal.
I guess the problem would have been that a sales failure would threaten long term income. To this I say, don't forget the DS was excellent backup even 18 months ago, and even at its weakest Nintendo's brand and daughter franchises were strong enough to maintain sustainability. This is also an Apple tactic: Have a hardcore fanbase that will support you when times are tough. Finally I ask would you call it a risk if they didn't have any home console alternatives?