
Last week we learned that Nintendo President of Japan Satoru Iwata felt the Wii is not in a “healthy” state and with the release of Electronic Art’s earning report yesterday it seems that EA, being the most prolific third party publisher on the Wii, can’t seem to avoid having the same feelings. Although EA is making the most profit with the Wii than any other console, “revenue is well below expectations due to underperformance of the Wii platform,” EA’s John Schappert told a conference call full of investors.
“I think the Wii platform has been a little weaker than we had certainly anticipated. And there is no lack of frustration to be doing that at precisely the time where we have the strongest third-party share,” EA CEO John Riccitiello said.
“. . . we are reaching out to Nintendo to find ways to partner to push third-party software harder. I frankly think they need more beats in the year than they get out of a first-party slate to be able to have the Wii software platform perform as well as they would like and we are building the products that I think are the most highly rated on the platform and at this point in time, generating the most revenue of any third party platform.”
Fans know that Nintendo’s strength lies in its first party titles and they’ve been asking for more of them despite Nintendo’s plan to trickle them out slowly. It may be an encouraging thought for Nintendo fans to know they’re not alone in wanting more first-party titles. But for Nintendo it may be a sign that the Wii is on shaky ground, when EA’s CEO says more first party titles are needed throughout the year to help reinvigorate the Wii.
You can read the whole earnings call transcript here.
Edit:
As reader Eolirin points out:
I think [Riccitiello]’s saying that Nintendo cannot possibly do it all with first party, and that EA can step up to provide necessary third party support so that there’s more consistent must have software for the platform.
The whole outreach to Nintendo thing is a way to shore up those two dovetailing interests; Nintendo needs more games, EA needs more product sales.
This sounds more like what Riccitiello had in mind. Although he does say the Wii needs more games and EA is there to provide them, I’m sure Nintendo fans would love to see more first-party titles instead of Littlest Pet Shop sequels.

Wait, I don't think that's what he's saying at all… I think he's saying that Nintendo cannot possibly do it all with first party, and that EA can step up to provide necessary third party support so that there's more consistent must have software for the platform.
The whole outreach to Nintendo thing is a way to shore up those two dovetailing interests; Nintendo needs more games, EA needs more product sales.
I think it's interesting to hear a major game company ask what is essentially its huge competitor to make more games. I hope Nintendo listens up, because while the first-party titles have generally been strong, they haven't been very steady.
They can't make up their minds. First they complain that it's too difficult competing with Nintendos first party efforts on their own platform, then they bitch that Nintendo is not putting out enough great first party games. What?
Seriously EA, take my advice. No really, just try it. MAKE A BUNCH OF GREAT GAMES FOR THE WII. Yep, thats it.
No, don't dumb everything down. Don't "target the demographic". Just make fucking awesome games. It's that simple. Don't make an on rails shooter. Just make a shooter. Don't toss the Wii a shit port, make a ground up game. I know it seems crazy that great ground up games will sell better than dumbed down versions of HD games, but trust me, they will. And if you want to kick me 5 percent when you follow my advice and see sales skyrocket, no sweat.
I think we could do with fewer Littlest Pet Shop games and more Boom Bloxes, for sure, but EA does have some good titles and IP on there (like Boom Blox). I have no problem with them continuing to focus on putting out games like that, and I'd be just as happy to see them fill the empty space as Nintendo, as long as they do it right. Less filler nonsense and more Tiger Wood 10s, etc.
Some good points but I wonder, if you'll permit me to go off on a bit of a tanget, if this problem couldn't be solved by Nintendo's marketing department. The biggest problem the Wii has is that the types of games EA are on about – the more traditional games that would appeal to more traditional gamers – aren't selling as well as they should because the gamers that would like them don't own Wii's. They've shunned it as a casual system and so, whilst many of us have bought great third party 'hardcore' titles like Madworld or No More Heroes, they aren't selling as much as they perhaps might if they were released on the 360.
If Nintendo worked with third parties – as EA are suggesting – and got a block of really good hardcore titles sorted, all being released within a month or two of each other, Nintendo could do a massive 'Hardcore Wii' marketing campaign which might entice more of the finicky traditional gamers to invest in their platform.
Nintendo have conquered the casual market, I'd love it if they could now conquer the hardcore as well. They've got the games, they just need to get rid of the – misplaced, I feel – casual image.
…of course I could just be being incredibly naiive and trusting in the 'hardcore' :P.
Don't release a gimped version of Rock Band on Wii. Don't say games don't sell when you don't release quality games.
@Phil Myth, Wait, EA's Wii games are primarily sports and casual titles. And the big marquee ones, like Tiger Woods and Grand Slam Tennis, all sold pretty well. Dead Space Extraction is really the only "hardcore" EA game on the system. Tiger Woods, Boom Blox and EA Sports Active are the big success stories there. So the not enough marketing to hardcores is a bit off; there's nothing from EA *to* market to hardcores. But besides that, I think that's probably an impossible task anyway. The more a gamer is of the "hardcore gamer" mentality, the more graphics are going to matter to them. You can't really win that market segment. It's just that the margins on that market sector are not really sustainable, so it's going to collapse. When EA is saying that it's most profitable sector is digital only and mobile, something's very very wrong. Their revenues are high, but the development costs eat almost everything.
@EdEN, Rock Band 2 sold pretty well on the Wii I thought? I mean, it's not quite as good as the others, but there are system limitations that make it harder to do right. And they improved over the first outing a LOT with regard to that.
Very true and that's my point, EA should make some kick ass hardcore titles, along with some other developers, Nintendo included, and release them all around the same time and have a hardcore marketing blitz.
But as you say, the graphics thing is a bit of a bitch…