Intelligent passion for all things NintendoNew to Infendo? Start here ↗
← Back to the journal
Infendo / An independent perspective

Which Nintendo IP should try changing genres?

Nintendo is working with Tecmo-Koei to have The Legend of Zelda made into a Hack and slash game and Retro reinvented Metroid as a First person shooter. What other Franchises could jump game styles and still retain their core ideas? Maybe Fire Emblem could become a standard JRPG in the vein of Suikoden with its […]

Nintendo is working with Tecmo-Koei to have The Legend of Zelda made into a Hack and slash game and Retro reinvented Metroid as a First person shooter. What other Franchises could jump game styles and still retain their core ideas?

Maybe Fire Emblem could become a standard JRPG in the vein of Suikoden with its multitude of characters and would still have some strategic elements of the previous games. Hopefully the upcoming crossover with Shin Megami Tensei will go in this direction.

This is going to be interesting

Another possibility is Kid Icarus becoming a pure on-rails shooter. The flying segments of Kid Icarus: Uprising were really impressive and had exciting gameplay, but once Pit touched the ground the controls fell apart and it spoiled a great game.

If only the whole game was this

So which Franchise would you like to see dabble in another genre?

More to discover.Keep exploring ↗
Infendo community

Join the conversation

32 comments

Share your perspective. Keep it thoughtful, welcoming and on topic.

  1. They were certainly hard to get used to, but I love the fact that they're just…different. And after much practice, I came to regard them as one of the best parts of the game.

  2. I don't think Nintendo shied away from the fact that the KI controls were awkward. Plus it was in every review.

    I mentioned this somewhere else, but as far as crossovers, why does every Mario game just have Mario characters? Playing as Toad sucks. Why not have Donkey Kong or Sonic as an optional character? There are tons of choices obviously.

    Or what about a Zelda RPG? I love how Fire Emblem keeps throwing new characters at you – what if you had a Zelda game like that, using various characters from past games? It would be fun battling with sages, or skull kid, merchants… think of all the choices.

  3. Legend of Zelda – turn based JRPG

    Pokemon – Fighting game (featuring fighting type pokemon mainly, would be very difficult to make every pokemon ever included in the game)

    Metroid – Open world sandbox space 3rd person action adventure.

    Can't think of anything else right now.

  4. I would love see a Pokemon MOBA, way more than a pokemon MMO. Also a stealth based free-roam Pokemon Snap would also be awesome.

    I'd also love to see Nintendo revamp the Ice Climbers and turn it into a 3D platformer with tons of exploration and collecting, much like Banjo Kazooie.

    A 3D non-side scrolling Kirby would be cool as well. They could either giver Kirby limited flight like in Smash or design the game around Kirby flying everywhere.

  5. hm this one is kind of tricky but…

    Star Fox- Goes completely Sandbox Land, Sea, Air and Space
    Legend of Zelda- Go to a GTA Style Sandbox
    Mario- Level editor game
    Donkey Kong- Return to open 3D from the N64
    Kirby- Super Mario 64 3D gameplay
    Zelda- Her own game (Duh not including CDi)
    Pokemon- Open Sandbox Free to play MMO or MOBA
    Fire Emblem- JRPG or Action RPG
    Ice Climbers- Revive franchise to 3D or 2 and a Half D
    F-Zero- Completely reboot franchise
    Animal Crossing- Racing, sports, etc similar to Mario Kart and so on

    Now I'm leaving out some franchise but here is a good list to start out.

  6. Would Nintendo ever consider reboots? They seem stubborn and keep adding to their franchises no matter how convoluted the storylines get. Star Fox really needs a reboot though I doubt it would ever happen which is a shame.

    Open world Metroid would be brilliant as would a Zelda RPG.

  7. I don't worry too much about Nintendo storylines, because the games are so fantastic to play. Now the Kingdom Hearts storyline: that's what you call convoluted.

  8. I feel like Nintendo already messes with the core gameplay of its series too much as it is. When you buy a sequel to something, there are expectations that are in place about what that game should be. It is absolutely fine to inject something new into an existing game ala co-op multiplayer in Super Mario Bros. I think it's less acceptable when the gameplay in a series is changed entirely (ala Kid Icarus 1+2 to Kid Icarus Uprising).

    Nintendo has lots of neat gameplay concepts, so why not flesh them out and create new universes for them? Not to start a crap-storm, but a very good example is Metroid Other M. One of the big things that people have voiced about Other M is that it doesn't feel like a Metroid game to them. But what if Other M had been its own thing and not a Metroid game? To stand on its own feet and have its own universe, it could have been interesting. Another great example is Star Fox Adventures, a game that had Star Fox thrown in at the end of development. It's probably a pretty decent game, but it sure as hell isn't a Star Fox game. It should've remained as Dinosaur Planet and given the chance to grow into its own thing.

    So I'd say, no, don't change the genres of core Nintendo games. Strengthen the gameplay, add new, interesting wrinkles, and flesh out the universes. When you have radical new gameplay concepts, you use them in games and universes designed around them and give them a chance to potentially grow into something wonderful and unique.

  9. I thought Kid Icarus: Uprising was amazing, both the flying AND land sequences. And I think people think it's good enough not to sell back to Gamestop. I lost my copy of the game a year ago, and just recently went to buy a used copy with a coupon… went to five Gamestops before finding the one that had ONE used copy.

  10. And a random Essel Appears…

    Did Someone mention Kingdom Hearts? I must say, it is one of my favorite series of all time. However, I do not find it unfathomable or convoluted at all, assuming that one has played all of the games and paid attention to the storyline as they were playing.

    Also, would love to see Nintendo mix things up a bit by crossing some of their franchises with each other. Put Mario in an FPS type game with various flowers/shells/etc as weapons. Put Zelda in a mario-esque platformer. Put Metroid in a pikmen-esque type game where Samus crashes on a planet and has to use the environment to reach her goal.

    None of these should be taken too seriously by Nintendo and they should have fun with it. Maybe sprinkle in some other forgotten characters such as Toe Jam & Earl (I know -not nintendo, but that would be the fun of it).

  11. keep up the nice work on the site. I love it. Could maybe use some more updates more often, but im quite sure that you got better or other stuff to do like we all do.
    michael kors sloan handbag
    [url=http://www.southsideartcenter.com/db/michael-kors-sloan-handbag.html]michael kors sloan handbag[/url]

  12. You’ll find a handful of fascinating points at some point inside the following paragraphs but I do not know if they all center to heart. There exists some validity but Let me take hold opinion until I look into it further. Great post , thanks and then we want a whole lot much more! Included in FeedBurner at the same time
    ladies barbour international waxed jacket
    [url=http://www.armada-online.com/includes/ladies-barbour-international-waxed-jacket.html]ladies barbour international waxed jacket[/url]

  13. Resources such as the one you mentioned here will be extremely helpful to myself! Ill publish a hyperlink to this web page on my personal blog. Im certain my site visitors will discover that very useful.
    white michael kors crossbody
    [url=http://www.psp.edu/db/white-michael-kors-crossbody.html]white michael kors crossbody[/url]

  14. Youre so right. Im there with you. Your blog is absolutely worth a read if anyone comes across it. Im lucky I did because now Ive obtained a whole new view of this. I didnt realise that this issue was so important and so universal. You undoubtedly put it in perspective for me.
    coach handbag malaysia outlet

  15. I admire the valuable data you offer inside your content. Ill bookmark your weblog and also have my youngsters verify up right here frequently. Im very certain theyll learn a lot of new things right here than anyone else!
    tory burch wedge flip flops on sale

  16. Some webmasters try to apply articles from free substance directories to make visitors to their internet site and make some money. This is mostly large for those who have only begun working as an affiliate for different companions and do not still have any support, yet need to develop small niche sites to visitants to their internet site so that they can start out making revenue.
    michael kors bracelet

  17. It isn’t often that you come across a article like this one. We’ll be sure to check back in to see what’s changed. Thank you for taking the initiative to write that article.
    michael kors 2013 outlet

  18. It’s rare for me to uncover something on the web that’s as entertaining and intriguing as what you have got here. Your page is sweet, your graphics are excellent, and what’s far more, you use source that are relevant to what you’re saying. You might be certainly 1 in a million, effectively done!
    buy michael kors watches australia

  19. I found your weblog site on google and check a couple of of your early posts. Proceed to maintain up the very great operate. I just extra up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Searching for ahead to reading extra from you later on!…

This discussion is closed to new comments.

Infendo · Play. Listen. Discover.

Your next discovery awaits.

Stay in the loop
Privacy & browser progress

Reading, listening and game progress lasts for this page without preference permission; with permission, this browser remembers for one year. Rating badges follow your saved ratings, independently of that preference. Analytics permission separately controls analytics and CRM reporting. Resetting browser progress does not delete CRM records.

Want to keep your points? Sign in →
Sign in