Intelligent passion for all things NintendoNew to Infendo? Start here ↗
← Back to the journal
Journal / An independent perspective

Poll – Guitar Hero 5 vs Beatles Rock Band

Well, it’s time for another round of rhythm game show down.  This week we want to know: From the archive Which do you want? Recovered historical results Beatles Rock Band35% 144 selections Guitar Hero 5 + Van Halen14.6% 60 selections Both7.3% 30 selections Neither43.2% 178 selections 412 recorded selections. Percentages use recorded selections. Voting closed […]

marshhero

Well, it’s time for another round of rhythm game show down.  This week we want to know:

From the archive

Which do you want?

Recovered historical results

Beatles Rock Band35%

144 selections

Guitar Hero 5 + Van Halen14.6%

60 selections

Both7.3%

30 selections

Neither43.2%

178 selections

412 recorded selections. Percentages use recorded selections.

Voting closed · historical results

JavaScript is needed for interactive voting. Available historical results are shown above.

More to discover.Keep exploring ↗
Infendo community

Join the conversation

12 comments

Share your perspective. Keep it thoughtful, welcoming and on topic.

  1. Come on people, we need more neither. We must revolt against the exploitation of these franchises!

  2. i'll probably end up going with gh5 just because of van halen. but i'll still feel bad for supporting them because gh5 has one of the worst setlists in guitar hero history.

  3. I voted neither. Im sick of the 80 GH games that are out there. Activision just running the series into the ground like they did with tony hawk. Rock band still kinda cool i guess.

  4. The Beatles will be great (I hope, but playing Twist & Shout is going to piss off my neighbors), but otherwise I'm waiting for GH5 to hit the bargain bin. It adds nothing worthwhile.

  5. I bought Guitar Hero 2 back in the day because rhythm games were fun and exciting. Then I played a lot of Rock Band due to the addition of vocals and drums. Since then I found the genre has been pretty stale.

  6. I will not spend any more money on Guitar Hero anything. Not since my first World Tour drum kit didn't work out the box and my replacement broke 3 days later. Not that it ever worked anyway since the sensitivity was all wrong.

    Those things were solved eventually, but the DLC released in the UK for GH:WT has been so unbelievably dire that I will not touch anything they do. They promised fantastic support for World Tour and it was nowhere to be seen, so I wouldn't pin my hopes on the GH5 setlist improving through DLC – they'll just ship GH6 instead.

    Since I was never really satisfied by GH:WT, I'll now be getting Beatles RB and if I like what I see, then I'll be getting RB2 as well.

  7. Hi, I'm Nintendo's readership!

    I'm voting "neither", because hating music games is the current trend! Yes, I secretly still play them with friends over a beer or two, but don't tell anyone lest I look uncool. Yessir, I'm an original, that I am! A real free-thinker!

This discussion is closed to new comments.

Infendo · Play. Listen. Discover.

Your next discovery awaits.

Stay in the loop
Privacy & browser progress

Reading, listening and game progress lasts for this page without preference permission; with permission, this browser remembers for one year. Rating badges follow your saved ratings, independently of that preference. Analytics permission separately controls analytics and CRM reporting. Resetting browser progress does not delete CRM records.

Want to keep your points? Sign in →
Sign in