Intelligent passion for all things NintendoNew to Infendo? Start here ↗
← Back to the journal
Infendo / An independent perspective

Contest: Argue the greatest Disney movie ever, win Guilty Party for Wii

Wanna win a copy of Disney’s Guilty Party for Wii? To win the sleeper game, make the most convincing argument for the greatest Disney movie ever in the comments below, including your name and town, and we’ll announce the winner on Friday’s podcast. Good luck!

Wanna win a copy of Disney’s Guilty Party for Wii? To win the sleeper game, make the most convincing argument for the greatest Disney movie ever in the comments below, including your name and town, and we’ll announce the winner on Friday’s podcast. Good luck!

More to discover.Keep exploring ↗
Infendo community

Join the conversation

24 comments

Share your perspective. Keep it thoughtful, welcoming and on topic.

  1. Quite obviously the best Disney movie ever is every gamers dream, being sucked into the game and having to fight your way out, Tron is the clear choice. Not much convincing is needed, just two words "light bikes." Who doesn't want one!? Cool vehicles, costumes (Tron-Guy anyone?), and a sequel on the way (which look freakin' sweet!) Tron=Best Disney movie ever! (you were thinking maybe "Air Bud?")
    -Rory, Green Bay, WI

  2. Greatest Disney movie ever? I will assume that we stick with their main Disney brand and not Touchstone or Hollywood Pictures Etc.
    For technical achievement and pure lasting power I do believe that there is only one choice, and that is Snow White and the Seven Dwarves. Without question this movie impresses audiences then and now over 75 years later. I loved it as a child and my children love it and 100 or 1000 years from now I am certain it will be the same.

  3. A GOOD movie includes a few of the following – Good acting, captivating plot, special effects, action, humor, surprises, attractive leading characters and rewatchability. A GREAT movie will contain all of the above features. I think Disney's recent Prince of Persia embodies all of these elements.
    So what exactly makes this a great movie?

    Characters. Both of the main characters are attractive (my wife says that the hero is a hunk, and the Princess is indeed a nice piece of eye candy), plus they are very well spoken. The cast of supporting characters is just amazing. From a funny government hating, tax avoiding, ostrich loving, not-quite-so-bad-after all rouge, and his incredible knife throwing side-kick, to true-to-form dashing brothers who do a wonderful job of portraying life in this medieval time, to some really despicable villians. This film did a fantastic job of picking characters to best portray what it was after.
    Story. The story grabs your attention from the very first moment, and never lets it ago until the very end. Add to that a nice surprise at the conclusion, and you've got yourself a real winner.
    Special Effects. All you have to do is watch this film for a few minutes to realize what a stunning job of special effects that they did with this movie. It's not necessarily gratuitous over-the-top kind of special effects, but rather the kind that both highlight and compliment the story itself.
    Action – Lots and lots of action. What more could you ask of a great movie.
    Comedy – There are many scenes that will make you laugh out loud. It's not a pure comedy, but it infuses enough laughs throughout the movie to make it very enjoyable.
    Rewatchability – My son and I have already watched it at least 4 times, and will definitely be watching it again some time soon. Even my wife enjoys sitting down with us and watching it for a second or third time.
    And finally this movie was based on a video game. Very few movies have what it takes to go from being a console game to a Block Buster movie. This movie does that with style.

    Even though this isn't one of Disney's Classic movies, I think it embodies all of the best elements of movie magic, and presents us with a modern day classic that will still be fun to watch many years down the road.

    – Mark, Owensboro, KY

  4. I would say that Aladdin (1992) is Disney's greatest movie.

    It'd take pages of explaining why Aladdin is truly the best, so I'll try to summarize what I like best… the underlying theme.

    The movie starts right out with a song, which sets the tone and creates a distinct atmosphere. The clever scene after the intro song involves a merchant, first offering the viewer some of his wares, then ultimately telling the story of an old oil lamp he has.

    The movie then really gets started, and all the characters are introduced gradually. I won't go over the whole plot, but I find each character to have their own charm. Aladdin is a so-called 'street rat', an outlaw often chased by the palace guards in Agrabah. Princess Jasmine is the princess of said city.

    The clever thing about the characters is that they both want what the same thing: freedom. Aladdin wants to be respected, live in the palace, not have to run for his life… while Jasmine doesn't want to be forced to be married and wants to move freely about outside the palace. This quest for freedom plays a certain role throughout the whole story as the characters meet. The Genie, who is to grant three wishes of whoever frees him from the Lamp the story started with, also desires the same freedom… and in the end, Aladdin will have to choose between the Genie's true freedom or his own. A selfless choice ultimately leads to the best possible ending for everyone (besides the villain).

    Besides the wonderful theme, the overall atmosphere, brilliant villain, heartwarming songs and beautiful visuals all make this into a movie worth watching for absolutely everyone.

    My name is Arjen, and the town I live in is Steenwijk.
    (Names sound weird? That's because I'm from the Netherlands.)

  5. Psh, easy. The greatest Disney movie every is Beauty and the Beast. It was the first animated movie to be nominated for the Best Picture Academy Award (and the reason for the category of Best Animated Film), and for good reason.

    The story is excellently written; Disney hired a screenwriter for the film, which was highly unusual for animation. They had to figure out how to take a story that was essentially two people having dinner every night, and turn it into an engaging 80 minute musical. The characters are well-written, and the use of household objects as supporting characters was inspired.

    The casting in this film was excellent. All of the actors provided their characters' singing voices, something that wasn't repeated until The Princess and the Frog. Robbie Benson, who played the Beast, was able to provide an incredible variety of voices for the same character.

    The film's commentary on masculinity is incredibly well done as well, to the point where it's easy to miss outside of a women's studies course. Gaston is the embodiment of mach0-man masculinity, as evidenced by the lyrics to his song (praising him as a perosn for his amazing abilities, such as his ability to spit and eat a lot of eggs). His macho personality is obviously highly negative; we all agree with Belle that Gaston is a monster, and we roll our eyes at the Bimbettes, who can't see past Gaston's looks. When we meet the Beast, he engages in childish, immature masculinity, as well as entitlement; he expects everyone to do what he wants, and when he doesn't get his way, he throws a tantrum. It's not until he learns to care about Belle, show kindness and respect to the rest of the characters, and make sacrifices for the people he loves, does he then represent ideal masculinity and maturity.

    The music in this film is timeless and gorgeous. The musical numbers are extremely creative. The first song introduces the characters in the village and explains the village's attitudes towards Belle as well as Gaston's motives. "Gaston" brilliantly lampoons macho-masculinity while advancing the story. "Be Our Guest" is a glamorous, catchy number, and "Something There" manages to advance the relationship between Belle and the Beast within the constraints of a short movie. And the best part is listening to the instrumental portions of the soundtrack, which contain repeated motifs and subtle transitions between themes.

    This movie is memorable, entertaining, and timeless. It was constructed with care, passion, and serious attention to detail. It's one of the best movies of all time, and certainly the best Disney film!

    – Stephanie, Brookline, MA

  6. WallE!

    The little robot was a compelling character, I loved the way WallE continued to do its best to make its environment better even though it was the only person/robot left on the planet. And there was a message too: the trashed planet and the humans on the space liner who had lost all ability to really live. The robot gained its humanity & hunans had lost it.

    Of course, it all ended up OK in the end. But I won't go there (don't want to spoil it for anyone).

  7. As a Disney geek, I can't pick just one out of at least a dozen awesome contenders. And as a contributor, I'm disqualified anyway….

    But I can tell you Disney's most under-rated great film:

    A Goofy Movie.

  8. For the sake of determining the greatest Disney movie of all time I'll have to set up some criteria. For starters, the film in question will have to be released under the Disney brand (this excludes some of the greatest films released by the company under the Miramax label, such as Pulp Fiction, but if we opened up that floodgate the entire game would be thrown out of balance). Second, it must be filmed by Disney studios, which will exclude another wave of excellent titles, including everything by Pixar and the entire Pirates of the Caribbean series. Finally, and this essentially includes all the other criteria, but I list it last for the sake of suspense, it must have been made under the direct supervision of Walt Disney himself. This automatically excludes all of this generation's favorite films, which encompasses everything after The Jungle Book, Winnie the Pooh and the Blustery Day, and The Happiest Millionaire; unfortunately this includes my childhood favorite Pete's Dragon, but in the name of fairness, sacrifices must be made.

    Looking back at Disney's personal legacy, we find a nice long legacy of pure artistic tripe. Almost everything good we remember about classic Disney cartoons was narrated by Sebastian Cabot in some rose-tinted in-house documentary designed to recruit employees. He was a brilliant businessman and organized his share of brilliant innovations, but aside from the concept of a theme park very few good artistic ideas actually came from his head.

    I can say with complete resolution that his feature-length film he produced are, without exception, completely devoid of any overall artistic value. They have their individual merits; Snow White was a very concise, visually unified take on the fairy tale, Sleeping Beauty had an exceptional visual style that resembled a storybook practically frame-to-frame, and Bambi and The Jungle Book simply have some of the best animal animation to this day. But alas, overall it's all garbage. If I limited myself to picking the best feature length Disney film, it would be impossible to pick one for its own value because they each have none; only significant contributions to the field as a whole can differentiate them.

    However, expanding the spectrum a bit, you find that Disney did produce a tremendous number of animated shorts. The majority of these are just charming musical cartoons, usually with absurd non-stories that are really just a vehicle for musical scenarios, or extremely trivial stories about on par with any Looney Tunes short. But scattered here and there is the occasional diamond in the rough; little gems of storytelling that pack a lot of emotion and character into a small package. The Winnie the Pooh shorts are pretty good, and Pecos Bill was loads of fun, but my favorite out of everything I've seen is The Whale Who Wanted to Sing at the Met.

    This oft-forgotten gem is one of the most emotionally jarring and meaningful; even though the situation is absurd (a sperm whale has the miraculous ability to sing and tries to impress the impresario of the Metropolitan Opera), it realistically addresses the gap between expectation and reality, perception and opportunity. The Whale Who Wanted to Sing at the Met is not as well-animated as many other pieces, nor is the art direction completely consistent or the final product particularly polished, but it makes up for its shortcomings by touching us and telling a story that really matters.

    Still, since everyone else is being much more broad and voting for Prince of Persia, Wall-E, and Beauty and the Beast, which are all completely out of my criteria for qualification, my first off-hand impression of best Disney movie is Pulp Fiction. No more to say there; there are probably better movies I can't remember off-hand, but that one totally kicks Walt's ass so it deserves the prize.

  9. There are a lot of great Disney movies, but the best is the Lion King.

    Unlike many of Disney's classics, this is an original story which I think adds to its greatness. The animation of course is brilliant, but it's the characters that really make this movie. Any self-respecting gamer must be a Star Wars fan, so having James Earl Jones as the father (Mufasa) is perfect. Matthew Broderick as Simba was also a great choice, as Simba basically spends the middle of the movie channeling his inner Ferris Bueller.

    Timon and Pumbaa steal the show of course. How many times did you catch yourself singing or saying Hakuna Matata after that movie came out? Yeah, me too. They were the perfect carefree, rowdy buddies that everyone loves to have. Jeremy Irons as Scar, Robert Guillaume as Rafiki, Cheech Marin as Banzai…. these are all great characters backed up by great actors with voices perfect for animated movies.

    The music was great as always, but again, Disney branched out from the norm here and turned to Elton John and Tim Rice for the big musical pieces. Can You Feel the Love Tonight, Circle of Life and Hakuna Matata were all nominated for an Oscar, with Can You Feel the Love Tonight winning. Hans Zimmer's score also won an Oscar.

    As a guy (and a gamer) this movie stands above all other Disney movies. The circle of life theme, the first time Simba is shown to the masses, the death of Mufasa, singing with Timon and Pumbaa, exacting revenge on Scar… this movie just has a ton on great moments.

    Robin Williams as Aladdin is probably the best Disney character, but the rest of the movie is rather bland. Beauty and the Beast is visually stunning, but it just doesn't have a lot of signature scenes. Also, I'm not counting Pixar movies since Disney basically just bought that franchise.

    Marc / Cleveland, Oh

  10. I'm glad that Lion King didn't get missed out as a nominee. That's my favorite Disney Movie. I remember after the movie hit VHS, the local top-40 radio morning show ran a contest to see if people could tell if the JEJ quote came from Star Wars or from Lion King.

    "You are my son" and "I am your father", are very close quotes. 🙂

    Not interested in the game, so not going to sell the point further than the gentleman above me, I just thought that I'd give my 2¢ on the topic.

    -Llaffer from the State of Confusion 🙂

  11. Lion King.

    For how many YEARS, count them, YEARS did you spend still *SPOILER ALERT* crying when Mufasa died? That gut wrenching, soul crashing king? And when Simba goes up to his dad, trying to wake him up… see, i'm actually tearing up right now!

    That is what defines a movie, a response that engages multiple audience from different cultures and beliefs with emotion, not dialogue or grandeur.

    All Disney movies are great, or at the very least good, but Lion King continues to be a powerhouse of emotion. Those that are spoken and unspoken.

    p.s.: WALL-E was an amazing film that is dear to my hear!

  12. As discussed above, it's difficult to set criteria for "Greatest Disney Movie Ever." I would argue that the Disney-Pixar film 'Up' meets such subjective standards, including ones posted above: writing, theme, character development, music (although there are no traditional Disney musical numbers, the score is simply brilliant and a lovely and compelling piece taken on its own), originality, etc. -I would also like to take a quick moment to point out to Marc that while the Lion King is a fabulous movie, it is not an original story, nor even an African one. It's a family-friendly version of Hamlet.- What I love about 'Up' is its very real and very adult emotions wrapped up in a whimsical story.

    The first five minutes of 'Up,' the story of Ellie's and Carl's life together, makes me cry every time I've seen it, and I think my husband and I have seen it seven or eight times by now. The excitement and anticipation of a new addition to your family, only to have such joy taken from you by no fault of you own is heart-wrenching and all to familiar to us. And it's referenced in the first five minutes of the film. They go on to live a fulfilling and content life when Carl loses Ellie. Anyone that's found that one person that makes their entire day brighter knows how truly painful this must be. Especially since Carl is left to carry on while the world literally closes in on the life they shared together.

    So he leaves. And inadvertently takes a little boy with him. A little boy who's homelife is not traditional, but has become common nowadays. "Phyllis isn't my mom," Russel says as if Carl should already understand this. The whole point of getting this badge is so his dad will come to the pinning ceremony. Of course by the end, Carl has learned that his life was always an adventure and that Ellie would want nothing more than for him to continue to live his life; and Russel, having fully assisted the elderly, gets his badge. While a touching momen,t as Carl presents him with the 'Ellie' badge, I believe it's worth noting that Russel's father is not at the pinning ceremony. A subtle reminder that even after an adventure, you don't always come home to a happy ending – at least not the happy ending you envisioned.

    The movie is colorful, fun, and as much a treat for the ears as the eyes. But it's themes are stark and very real, its emotions are heart-wrenching. It's fanciful while being reflective. It's a movie kids will think is fun and funny and, when they get a little older, will appreciate it for its simple and, at times, bitter sweetness.

    Also, there's a talking dog. Any dog owner will vouch for the earnestness of Doug. "I was hiding under the porch, because I love you." How do you not vote for the talking dog?

  13. name: Alex

    town: Fort McMurray

    Greatest ever?

    Easy: Pinnochio

    Why? Well, lets just say I'm not the only one with this opinion.

    This was one of the last movies Walt had direct involvement in. It has not only the 9 old men at their finest and purest animation genius (making modern animations seem paltry compared to this- just watch the clock scene in Gepetto's workshop) but it features a charming and powerful story. -and a dark one at that.

    The film rolls out like an epic, we start with a humble beginning in a small italian town and quickly watch the little wooden boy get taken advantage of, beat, abused, caged, corrupted and turning his back on his family and only friend.

    However, the character learns. He learns throughout his travels and in the end, even though he disobeyed and practically doomed Gepetto (and his pets Figaro and Cleo), he musters up all the strength and courage he has to redeem himself and rescue his father. He even goes so far as to practically drown.

    He ends up travelling the path of life. And a true journey of the hero. And on the way we meet fantastic characters: evil, friendly, monstrous and benevolent. We are also treated to a brilliant musical score.

    In fact, the movie and its music are so important that you hear the tune "when you wish upon a star" every time you see the disney logo before any disney movie starts.

    Pinnochio represents the apex for Disney animation and story telling. With only a few of their following titles reaching its greatness.

  14. OK SERIOUSLY…..LION KING NO DOUBT! Everyone takes way to long to summarize this for their argument. I on the other hand will keep it simple and make it the most convincing. It made me, a tough football sports jock, never show emotion type of guy cry. You herad me..LION KING MAKES GROWN MEN CRY. Name another cartoon that has a story and his father, there isnt many!. LION KING WINS..I cried and for a couple minutes became a sissy boy.

  15. Seriously, no one has said Cinderella. There is only an entire themepark centered around her castle. Add in the fact that the mice were hilarious (mmmmm Gus Gus). Come on is there a more classic and well known story like Cinderella? Jessica from Antioch, TN.

  16. I agree with MikeW. Wall-e was a great and fresh idea for all those people who actually pay attention to animations and the filming of movies. (this is all my films teachers fault). So according to me, the animation and idea of all the going into space, and the plant being a good symbol of life and all that jazz. I even bought it when it came out on DVD. And I got the cool case. That one that opens up from the side and has the disc in just a little thing-yeah I don't know what I'm really saying. But I guess what I'm saying is it was a good movie. And I just typed all this on the iPod so this took an eternity. 😀

  17. oops for got my name and town Hugo Cabrera Los Angeles REPOST: OK SERIOUSLY…..LION KING NO DOUBT! Everyone takes way to long to summarize this for their argument. I on the other hand will keep it simple and make it the most convincing. It made me, a tough football sports jock, never show emotion type of guy cry. You heard me..LION KING MAKES GROWN MEN CRY. Name another cartoon that has a story about a boy and his father, there isnt many! LION KING WINS..I cried and for a couple minutes became a sissy boy.

  18. Looks like Lion King has made a convincing argument for itself. Time for some intervention; I'll be explaining the flaws and why I don't think it's everything it's worked up to be (my thoughtfully obscure submission deserves a chance!).

    The Lion King isn't a bad film by any measure; it's visually slick, has some catchy songs, and the story certainly holds its own fairly well, but it suffers a little too hard from some classic Disneyisms to really be perfect. The message especially reflected too strongly a dated and backwards notion of nobility and racism; the "circle of life" was presented as a universal excuse for oppression and cruelty towards an entire species. It's a little disturbing to see a story where an oppressed minority revolting against a dismissive power is painted as so ugly and destructive and ultimately its slaughter and banishment being the resolution to all the world's problems.

    Yes, the quality of the film from a production standpoint is just great, but it's hard to get past the message when it's so ugly and unthoughtful.

    My two cents, anyway. Just thought I'd get that in before the podcast comes out.

  19. I love Lion King but I cannot say its the greatest Disney film ever. I think Lion King is heavily inspired by Kimba the White Lion, something I was so crazy about when they used to show it on the local channel in Saudi Arabia some 25 years ago. Don't get me wrong Lion King is amazing on its own and a very good story about triumph and all. But simply not as great as Pinocchio!

    Pinocchio is simply the greatest Disney movie ever IMHO. It has everything and it connects to you every time you watch it. It emotionally very powerful and I agree with gojiguy aka Alex that its quite easily the greatest. Snow White is also brilliant, but not as good as Pinocchio. Maybe, Snow White has more female backing because of obvious reasons. But once again, everyone watch these films again and you will eventually love Pinocchio!

This discussion is closed to new comments.

Infendo · Play. Listen. Discover.

Your next discovery awaits.

Stay in the loop
Privacy & browser progress

Reading, listening and game progress lasts for this page without preference permission; with permission, this browser remembers for one year. Rating badges follow your saved ratings, independently of that preference. Analytics permission separately controls analytics and CRM reporting. Resetting browser progress does not delete CRM records.

Want to keep your points? Sign in →
Sign in