Want to upgrade your Wii to the new black? Then you’ll have to hold on to your old Wii to play previously purchased games, forfeit them altogether, or buy them a second time, Wired reports.
“It shows extreme lack of foresight on their part,” says Wii owner Nathan Gillmore. “Did they really think the general public would be content to have all of their purchased content bound to a specific device?”
Much like non-transferable DSi downloads or playing games online with friends, it’s obvious Nintendo didn’t really think much about it. In other words, the company is great at making games, not so great at making operating systems, multiplayer networks, or user identification programs.
Wired reports that Nintendo might be willing to bend the rules if you call and plead with customer support. But not everyone is so lucky. And even then, you have to send both Wiis into Nintendo for them to make the switch, a snail mail process that takes two weeks to complete.
Of course, this is all at Nintendo’s discretion. It’s their business model. And they can do whatever they want, complaining nerds be damned. But I imagine 70+ million Wii owners will take issue with this at some point: either today in the hopes of switching to black, or when they ultimately decide to upgrade to Nintendo’s next home console.
What do you think of Nintendo’s single-system download policy? Since (some) cell phones do it, is it okay for Nintendo to do the same? Speak up, readers!

Which cell phones? I can install apps/games that I buy on more than one iPhone at home.
I honestly think this is stupid of them. Why not allow it but make the user register both systems on the same Club Nintendo account?
How does this work for Xbox 360 and PS3?
That was a good article. It makes me happy that I keep ALL of my bank statements, organized by date to boot. It makes me sad that I'd have to send my hardware off to Nintendo as a solution.
I'm with that analyst that hopes Nintendo get this sorted for their next home console. But I think I'll just keep my fingers crossed rather than hold my breath. Blue just isn't my color, especially when its my FACE!
This is an EPIC FAIL Nintendo. They need a way to sync to your PC or Mac, like their own iTunes like application.
"I'm with that analyst that hopes Nintendo get this sorted for their next home console."
As I explained to the Infendo crew in our dojo, this will be the case. For right now, however, why should Nintendo do this at all? As Wired states in this very same article (linked above), there is literally no dent in their bottom line (read: profits) as a result of this admittedly short-sighted practice. Why would Nintendo, a notoriously conservative company, throw money at a problem that does not exist. In the future it will, I whole-heartedly agree, which leads to…
BUT! When the time comes for a new Wii, you can bet your ass that the 100 million or so Wii owners (I'm thinking future install base here with that number) will be addressed. For now, the geeks who are negatively affected by this can bitch and moan or they can send in their Wii consoles to Nintendo as the people in the Wired article did. Maybe Nintendo will help them, maybe they won't. It's business. Nintendo is not "your friend" and if the practice negatively affects their profits they probably will not start "fixing" Wii's en masse until it makes financial sense to do so. At the moment, it makes no sense.
Related to this, I believe this gaffe by Nintendo pretty much proves there is no Wii HD console coming anytime soon.
This is so true….I had this problem. I have a new Wii and they will not let you transfer the stuff. Crazy as far as I am concerened since they can view your Club Nintendo Account…see what Wii's you have registered and allow the transfer. XBOX has a transfer cable people can use…Come on Nintendo! When I called Nintendo they didn't care or even offer for me to send in both consoles. Boo! to them on this issue.
Well, I'm sure Nintendo will allow for a way for us to migrate our accounts into their next console. Maybe after linking our Club Nintendo account to the new console we'll get access to our purchases for the Wii? Same could be true for 3DS and the DSi. That way you could have it on TWO consoles and problem solved. If there was a small licensing fee (thinking 10 cents per game) that would also be acceptable for me.
This is why if my Wii breaks down or I get a black one I won't feel the slightest bit guilty about using the homebrew channel to "replace" all the VC titles I bought.
And Nintendo would want to help you out why? I've already bought Mario 3 five times. Once on Nes, once on GBC, once for GBA, once on SNES as Mario All Stars, and again on my Wii.
It's a business, and that's how Nintendo rolls.
If I asked Nintendo to transfer my NES Mario 3 to my SNES they would laugh in my face. If I asked them to transfer Mario 3 to a new NES cartridge if mine broke, they'd laugh in my face. Why are people surprised?
That said, I no longer buy DLC of any kind, I like to keep my games separate from my console. Same goes for PC games that rely on internet activation, they can suck my … you know.
and nintendo forgets the online space. again.
weak sauce.
Yeah…to put it simply, this will be an important point for Nintendo to fix or there will be tons of consumers who will reconsider buying the future consoles. I'm sure by then they'll fix the problem, but until they do I wont be buying any online content from Nintendo.
"and nintendo forgets the online space. again. weak sauce"
Maybe for some. Definitely not week sauce for Nintendo though, or those gamers who don't notice these developments, which is "many."
But for those who really love to play online/transfer files? Perhaps. I'm sure it will be addressed eventually, when it makes business sense to Nintendo. Right now, it's a gnat on the windshield for this company.
well that's the weak sauce this week. other weeks, it's still weak. weekly, i hope for a week without the weak.
but the blue ocean doesn't care too much. and for this they will forever be labeled "casual."
i mean, "nontraditional."
(by the way, i think its OK to call out Nintendo for dropping the ball without whitewashing it with a "but Nintendo's still grrrrrrrrrreat!")
*(press "A" to use cover)
*presses A
😀
Its BS.
what i meant to say was:
yeah you geeks! stop bitching and moaning! how dare you stand in the way of profits!?!
Profits: that's the enron way! that's the goldman way! and that's the nintendo way!
you think they recalled the NES back in the day TO BE NICE?!?
HA!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"Profits: that's the enron way! that's the goldman way! and that's the nintendo way!"
Yup, the way of the world my friend.
Think of the Wii system as a choose your own adventure version of the Action 52.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0A65rU-RPqE
It's really kinda stupid. But knowing nintendo, they'll do something to fix this rather quickly. At least by the end of the year.
"Profits: that's the enron way! that's the goldman way! and that's the nintendo way!"
And the Microsoft way, the Apple way, the Sony way, the Samsung way, the LG way, the Verizon way, the AT&T way, the Kotaku way, the Game Informer way, the Activision way, the EA way, the Starbucks way, the Ubisoft way, the Capcom way, the Konami way, the Coke way AND the Pepsi way.
Seriously, what was the point of aligning Nintendo with Enron, et al? To allude to their 'evilness?' Are you really that heavy-handed and detrimental, or only play up on the haterade and drama because it's teh interwebz?
@herogear
actually, i was thinking that we praise nintendo for giving consumers what they want and being so interested in the consumer… but then give them a pass to easily when they drop the ball.
we see nintendo as looking for blue ocean in entertainment at times and have the creative teams describe how interested they are in providing new experiences. and this just doesnt sit well with the profit-motive excuses all shortcomings angle of some posts.
there's an inconsistency with how nintendo is presented in some posts, based on whether we need to defend shortcomings (who cares! no mkt demand!) or praise innovation (just what the consumer wanted!)
it's true that both can be explained through profit motive. but it's clear that theyre not. the presentation is troubling for that reason and suggests that some people want to give nintendo an excuse for anything they do in the best light possible. that's why the articles about the wiimote emphasize reaching out to people to bring them into the industry, instead of reaching out to bring their wallets into the industry. even the blue ocean talk used to have a kind and fuzzy edge compared to this, uh, excuse-ism.
mostly i was having fun with my post because it's in such stark contrast to the way nintendo is presented when people arent trying to excuse its shortcomings.
(ok, signing off from this name for real now! not planning to pull a brett favre here!)