Intelligent passion for all things NintendoNew to Infendo? Start here ↗
← Back to the journal
Infendo / An independent perspective

Just how "underpowered" are Wii’s graphics?

In light of recent comments made by Microsoft’s Robbie Bach in calling Wii’s graphics less capable than Xbox 1, N’Gai Croal examines the facts via three anonymous sources. Wii is a scrappy little booger, but is it as underpowered as conventional wisdom suggests? From the article: While Bach’s statement that the Wii is graphically underpowered […]

In light of recent comments made by Microsoft’s Robbie Bach in calling Wii’s graphics less capable than Xbox 1, N’Gai Croal examines the facts via three anonymous sources. Wii is a scrappy little booger, but is it as underpowered as conventional wisdom suggests? From the article:

While Bach’s statement that the Wii is graphically underpowered compared to the first Xbox wasn’t quite a bulls-eye, it’s so darned close to the mark–technically speaking–that we’ve got to compliment him on his aim. The question, then, is how much will developers be able to squeeze out of the less-flexible Wii hardware? But if the Wii keeps selling like ice on a hot summer day, it’s unlikely that Nintendo will lose too much sleep over the power disparity.

The gist: Wii’s graphics technology and processing power can closely be described as a “GameCube 1.5,” though as Croal reiterates, “doesn’t mean that gamers won’t see graphical improvements on the Wii.”

Still having trouble coming to terms with an underpowered Nintendo console? Believe it an enjoy it for what it is, or buy a PS3 and/or 360.

[Thanks, N’Gai!]

More to discover.Keep exploring ↗
Infendo community

Join the conversation

26 comments

Share your perspective. Keep it thoughtful, welcoming and on topic.

  1. People just can't handle the fact that a lesser powered system is more fun than anything around; the same goes for the DS.Would I enjoy better graphics on the Wii? Sure, but I'm enjoying this exciting style of gameplay and Nintendo inovation too much to worry about it.

  2. I really like how most games look on Nintendo systems, whether it's GameCube, handhelds, or Wii.The key, here, is that most NINTENDO games look good on their hardware. I've seen some scary looking graphics from other companies (Spider-Man 3 for Wii, some EA war game on the Cube).The games that usually look like crap are multi-console ports that don't get designed for the system from the ground up.I am perfectly happy with what Wii's graphics can do .. I'm less happy with the weak job some 3rd party companies do with their art design for Wii games.

  3. Digg has a link up a while ago to a PC site that benchmarked the Wii. End note said that it was more powerful then the Gamecube and Xbox put together. Wii is powerful it's just not been utilized. Hopefully Nintnedo will show that potential later this year.

  4. I, for one, am sick of people using the term "Gamecube 1.5". The Wii can do a lot of things that the Gamecube could never do in its wildest dreams. By the same comparison you could call Xbox 360 "Xbox 1.5" since it does a lot of the same things that the original Xbox does.

  5. The Gamecube's graphical power was on par with the Xbox's (and used better, less dated technology), so saying that the Wii isn't on par with the Xbox is is like saying that the Wii's graphical power is less than that of the Gamecube, which is ridiculous. I really hope the guy isn't that ignorant, being that he heads the entertainment division at Microsoft.

  6. I think scaling the power of the GameCube/Wii graphic chips is not as one-dimensional as some articles are trying to convey… In processing power, sure, the ATI "Hollywood" chip is less powerful than the Xbox's NVIDIA chip set, but only if you compare MHz. I always liked the GC's first-party graphics better than the Xbox's, but that only happens when they were built for the "Flipper" chip from the start. It is ports that are going to suffer.

  7. I believe that a false impression of the Wii's capabilities has been painted by the games to date.Currrently the most advanced game is still Zelda, made for gamecube and hardly pushing what eefcts can be achieved. Everything could practically be a psp port. Hardly representative.Take a look at what WAS achieved even on PS2. Shadow of the Collossus employed effects that either achieved or effectively faked HDR lighting, lighting bloom, self shadowing, soft shadowing, vector based motion blur, fur shading, a kind of specular effect, particle effecs, inverse kinematics, physics systems, and even a kind of sub surface light scatter effect.Add a normal map (achievable with two standard bump map passes), depth of field (achievable with a dsp process) and environment maps all over the place, and you're using the most potent graphical effects available, without even necessarily needing fully programable shaders.A little effort will go a long way, and I genuinely believe that while the difference will still be obvious, Wii can do some simplified form of everything PS3 and Xbox can do graphically, to a very pleasing effect.

  8. Oh, and sykil, as far as the graphics processors are concerned, the Xbox was indeed technically more powerful than the GameCube, but less than Wii (but not by much): Xbox => NVIDIA chipset = 233 MHzGC => ArtX chipset = 162 MHzWii => ATI "Hollywood" = 243 MHzBut, like I said, this is just raw processing power. I believe Nintendo used the power of the ArtX chip better than Xbox did with NVIDIA.

  9. The graphics may be underpowered, but I dont care. I enjoy the VC on the Wii (which is the main reason I wanted to get one in the first place).Then again, I never played many Gamecube games in the past, so I'm catching up on some classic Cube titles, so who cares about graphics? The Cube's graphics were pretty awesome!Over time we may see game developers stretch the Wii game graphics bit by bit.

  10. How many times will this be discussed? Obviously graphics don't matter (the history of videogame consoles has proved that many times). Watching the "weak" Wii graphics wont make your eyes burn. "Superrealistic graphics" are just there for nerds and geeks to feel "mature", but the truth is that no one cares.

  11. they're not that bad.. look at Dewy's Adventure… Yeah, it's weird, but the graphics are sweet!

  12. Really, the graphics have done all they need to for me. Even Zelda looks excellent. I mean, if you look at say, Sonic Heroes and compare it to SatSR, its a HUGE difference. Mario sunshine to Mario Galaxy is also a big difference. Wiis graphics are good enough for me.

  13. InvisibleMan: I meant in terms of what you're getting per cycle, not what speed the processor has been clocked at. The XBox used an old nVidia chip that didn't put out as much as what Flipper did per cycle.

    To be honest, I thought the last generation, especially the Gamecube, was effective graphically. It just needed better textures, and now we have more memory for that.

  14. I love my Wii (own over 15 games) and am a big Nintendo fan, but DAMN do Wii games look butt ugly on my HDTV, if only Nintendo had supported a 720P mode, even if it was upscaling most games!

    Seriously, when I play Xbox 1 games upscaled to 720P on the 360, they look 10 times better than Wii games!

    Almost all Wii games (with the exception of Zelda) look blurry and muddy, and yes I have official component cables.

    Very dissapointed in how weak the Wii games are, we were promised a system that outperforms an Xbox 1, but I have yet to see any games that prove this. And the Xbox 1 even supported 720P for some games!

  15. The Playstation 1 beat the Nintendo 64 AND went toe-to-toe with the Dreamcast before the PS2 was released. The PS2 beat both the Gamecube and the original Xbox. Hell, in the hand-held market we've had the monochromatic original gameboy outselling color systems!

    If everyone was so concerned over graphics than either Nintendo or Microsoft would have won the last generation. The reason people obsess over graphics is because, obviously, how a game looks is the very first thing ones sees, and as human being we have a tendency to make snap judgments based entirely on first impressions. This is also why we have people saying that the Wii can't even do Xbox 1 graphics, despite the fact that it is well documented that the Wii is more powerful than the original Xbox.

    But even so, historically it has always been the less technologically advanced video game system that has won each generation. The console with a breadth of entertaining games has always been the winner of each generation, regardless of the strength of the hardware. And it appears that this history is repeating itself yet again. Dropping out of the technological arms race was the smartest thing Nintendo has ever done. Advanced graphics are icing on the cake, but it's whether or not the game is fun that makes it popular.

    IMO, what Nintendo needs to do (and what I believe they may already be in the process of doing) is make a first-party game that really takes advantage of the Wii's hardware and shows off what it really can do. Did you take a really good look at the GDC 07 Super Mario galaxy footage? Looking pretty nice to far. Once Nintendo has a golden graphical example the third-parties can be held to there will be no more excuse for their blatant laziness in utilizing the Wii's hardware.

  16. Parabolee:

    It isn't that the Wii isn't technically capable of outputting HD resolutions (it's quite capable), it's that the exclusion of HD was a deliberate choice by Nintendo.

    If you own an HDTV then you are in the minority. The last numbers I've read stated that 28% of Americans own HDTVs, and that number was even less at the time the Wii was in development. Now, even assuming that each and every one of that 28% plays video games, that would still leave 72% of gamers on standard def, at the very least. But I think it would be more realistic to predict that the number of standard def gamers out there would number in the 80% + range.

    While HD is indeed a boon for gaming, HDTV owners still comprise a niche audience. Sony and Microsoft are aggressively pursuing that audience because HDTVs are a growing technology, practically destined to become the new standard within the next 10 years or so, and they hope to cash in on that growth by establishing themselves as leaders in the HD entertainment field ASAP.

    Nintendo is taking a more conservative stance on HD. They are waiting for HDTVs to acquire greater market penetration before investing in it. HDTVs will likely reach said greater amount of penetration in the next 5 or so years, right around the time Nintendo will already be working on their next video game console, so, to them, it really made more sense to hold off on banking on HD technology for the time being.

    That said, it would still be cool if the Wii outputted at 720p.

  17. Yes it's true the PS beat the N64 with less graphics, and the PS2 beat both the Xbox and GC with less graphics, but those leaps in graphics were nowhere near the gap between the Wii and PS3/Xbox360. It's true that later games SHOULD look better, but I think part of this is a backtrack from the first reports of it being more powerful than the Xbox or GC, and now 6 months into it's life, nothing has prove that yet.

  18. No, Caion, the percentages don't carry over like that. If you're just looking at gamers, a larger percentage of gamers have HD than the percentage of the total population. I'm pretty sure that the gaming market is where HD has penetrated most. Still, it's not exactly Nintendo's target market; their target market is everyone.

  19. "No, Caion, the percentages don't carry over like that. If you're just looking at gamers, a larger percentage of gamers have HD than the percentage of the total population. I'm pretty sure that the gaming market is where HD has penetrated most. Still, it's not exactly Nintendo's target market; their target market is everyone."

    I did consider that, but as nobody (at least as far as I am aware) has actually done a statistical survey of the ratio of HD to non-HD users in the video gaming market, any conclusions drawn to that end are pure speculation. I'm pretty sure that the number of HD users among gamers is higher than the general population, but how much higher remains to be seen.

    And, as you pointed out, Nintendo is looking towards the general public in terms of their target audience, so it's the numbers I've quoted that they are most interested in.

  20. Who cares?
    As long as the games are fun, the Gamecube1.5… I mean Wii will be great.

    We ALREADY have the PS3 and 360 for gamers who want HD top of the line graphics.
    We DONT need a third system that is the same, we need a third system that is focused on fun games, inovative controls and cheaper cost.

  21. People just can't handle the fact that a lesser powered system is more fun than anything around.

    Exactly… the Wii is FUN, and more FUN then any system I have played in a long time.

  22. I think Metroid Prime was on par graphically with Halo, if not better. Wii is definitely capable of better graphics than Xbox 1. Devs just need to stop making ports.

This discussion is closed to new comments.

Infendo · Play. Listen. Discover.

Your next discovery awaits.

Stay in the loop
Privacy & browser progress

Reading, listening and game progress lasts for this page without preference permission; with permission, this browser remembers for one year. Rating badges follow your saved ratings, independently of that preference. Analytics permission separately controls analytics and CRM reporting. Resetting browser progress does not delete CRM records.

Want to keep your points? Sign in →
Sign in