US vs. Japan Wind Waker Disc

Share your perspective. Keep it thoughtful, welcoming and on topic.

1. obviously US..its all about the gold zelda carts!!..or discs in this case..

2. The one that has less shitty map hunting on it. That pretty well ruined the game for me.

3. How anyone can criticize Wind Waker is beyond me. This was one of the best games of all time.I must have missed something because I didn't have any trouble sailing for long periods of time or "map hunting" whatever that is.

4. The guy who posted that on Flickr seemed to think the Japanese disc design was better. Why, I don't know, since they're practically identical.I saw a gold cart copy of Majora's Mask this weekend at a GameStop. Something a lot cooler about golden cartridges than golden discs. I'm surprised there was never a gold GameCube released in a Zelda bundle.

5. man they're both just so dang cool lookin

6. "How anyone can criticize Wind Waker is beyond me. This was one of the best games of all time."Nicholas, the endless sailing and obvious extension of the length of the game by scattering maps and Triforce pieces EVERYWHERE was a major complaint by countless gamers and in several reviews, even by huge fans of the Zelda series.As far as the average game goes, yes, Wind Waker was a great game. But compared to the rest of the Zelda series, it very well may be at the bottom of the barrell. A one-two punch like Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask was a hard act to follow, and many people felt that Wind Waker just didn't bring as much new, innovative, and fun to the series (other than the clearly different animation style, which was another major point of contention among fans… either you loved ir or hated it, generally speaking).I'm glad that Nintendo are taking their sweet time so they don't make the same mistake with Twilight Princess.

7. I would rather get another Wind Waker for the Gamecube & Twilight Princess on the Revolution. Whatever you might say its Zelda, is not a regular game you play once and that's it. This is like a mayor event in gaming. You guys complain for everything. Item Scavenging is a big part of the RPG genre, I can't believe you are not aware of that.

8. Meep! Where is the European disk? Gold FTW..

9. it took me ages to complete WW, its a massive game, and although all the sailing around can tire you out (in some cases, i got so frustrated i left it for a few months) its one of my favourite games, ever.you know im right.

10. Gold looks a whole LOT better!Also, the way it ties in with the design of the U.S. cover is excellent…

11. WHOOOOOO! ZELDA! woot! woot!

12. ….Aaaanyway, Wind Waker was great. No need to bring essays into this.I like the Japanese's color, but like InvisiMan sed, the gold disc goes together with the gold case like a black bra and panties. And in regards to its worth as a game, it was admittedly – by Shiggs' confession – artificially elongated with the Triforce piece search at the end because the team had cut out those 2 hard dungeons (to keep it accessible for wimps) and needed filler.That said, WW was magical to me- that grand feeling of being a little island boy out to save the world, the complete isolation you feel when you're searching for sunken treasure in the middle of the ocean at night, the look of it all. Basically it oozed atmosphere. If Wind Waker came with Twilight Princess graphics, it would've been a mediocore game in comparison. The adventure wasn't what made WW grande, which is why alot of ppl are quick to say it's the worst one. Just like Adventure of Link– it was different so it was unjustly deemed inferior.

13. I have to say, I really had no problem with the sailing. For one, you get to warp pretty early on eliminating most of the travel time. Before that, you are only required to travel short distances.Maybe others have trouble navigating and get lost easily. I remember hearing about people leaving their boat sailing while they went and did something else. No wonder it took so long, they probably sailed by it 4 or 5 times.I have no recollection of sailing long periods of time at all.

14. "Whatever you might say its Zelda, is not a regular game you play once and that's it. This is like a mayor event in gaming.You guys complain for everything. Item Scavenging is a big part of the RPG genre, I can't believe you are not aware of that."I played it once and that was enough for me.And item-whoring sure did not play anywhere near THAT big of a role in either Ocarina of Time or Majora's Mask, which IMO easily surpass Wind Waker as far as Zelda games go."I have to say, I really had no problem with the sailing. For one, you get to warp pretty early on eliminating most of the travel time. Before that, you are only required to travel short distances."But you have to play the stupid song every time you want to warp (and maybe you enjoyed that, but frankly I did NOT), and the warp system would have made sense if you could warp to any square on the map. But no.. you can only map to certain areas and you have to sail the rest of the way.Riding Epona in OOT and MM was fun. Sailing a boat for 12 years in WW was not. And if you have no recollection of sailing for remotely long periods of time, I'm afraid you didn't play the same game that I did.I didn't hate WW, but I would not recommend it to a first-time player who is new to the Zelda series. Ocarina of Time or Majora's Mask would be much better choices, far and away.

15. gold looks more ancient

16. I know this is off topic – – -But, what happened to 4CR?

17. Silence, blasphemer!There shall be no talk of 4CR in these hallowed webpages.Oh, and the cheap bastards had their site pulled because they hadn't paid their hosting bills -_-As for those "special" folks who dare criticize WW, maybe you'd be better off playing Halo and trash talk with your impatient buffoon peers.WW is a masterpiece, an orgy of perfect gameplay and atmosphere, and you're typing out of the final stage of your digestive system.

18. Hey, 4CR is a good site.

19. Patience is only sometimes considered a virtue, and then wrongly so.Anyway, why do you keep bringing up Majora's Mask? That was easily my least favorite Zelda (right ther with Zelda II). Constantly having to go back through the same time period was a little onerous… MUCH more so than sailing.So, riding a horse is okay but sailing isn't? This is clearly a personal preference, and I much prefer the water anyday… Even in real life.To be honest, I liked Oracina of Time but it was no where near my favorite. I'd rank them in this order: Wind Waker, A Link to the Past, Zelda I, Ocarina of Time, Zelda II, then Majora's Mask. I'm not saying any of the games were bad, but I enjoyed some more than others.I found the entire Wind Waker to be enjoyable. Yes, even the triforce hunt at the end. In fact, it reminded me a lot of the original Zelda where you hunt for Triforce pieces the ENTIRE time."But having the player turn the controller off and go take a shit while they wait for Link to reach the next island is not good game design." Again, this would be where you must have went around the entire world 5 times. If you had been looking at your map and navigating, you'd probably hit the location before you got the controller turned off. Question: did you get lost while trying to wipe your ass too?Sure, Wind Waker may not be everyone's favorite… But it was mine, and most people's complaints aren't fair ones.

20. (Sigh)I guess it's a love-it or hate-it thing.But it's several GOTY awards probably make up for this "shortcoming" (BWAHAHA)Whatever.4CR is a good site .. . if you like reading self-important, chest beating drivel. The story submitters make the site.

21. Also .. . can it be considered the game's fault if your navigation 'skills' suck? Lmao.

22. I can't recall ever getting lost while playing through. It usually went like this:-Open map-Look for next destination-Point wind towards next destination-Point ship towards next destination-Open sail-Go take shit-Wipe Ass(Which, most of the time, I can accomplish without flaw)-Return and wati a little wile longer before Link hets to next destination

23. its all about the gold disk gentlemen

24. -Open map-Look for next destination-Point wind towards next destination-Point ship towards next destination-Open sail-Go take shit-Wipe Ass(Which, most of the time, I can accomplish without flaw)-Return and wati a little wile longer before Link hets to next destinationI guess anyone can tell the toilet's not the only one that's full of shit.

25. Yeah, except for Shigeru Miyamoto and Eiji Aonuma. Heh, calling me full of shit. Cheap shot, that was. Your mother must be proud. Since it has come to this, I say let's just agree to disagree. We're not accomplishing anything here.

26. Cheap shot or not, everyone's clearly against your claims here.Oh, and don't twist that article you linked just to attempt back your claims, no one's buying it.Clearly, your straw-grasping is pathetic.Kthxbye.

27. Sure, I'm the only person in the world who thinks that Wind Waker was less than perfect. Everyone else agrees with you. I shouldn't have doubted you, oh master, for as we all know, your opinions are right. Whatever, fuck it.

28. Glad to have shown you the light, son.^_^Bwhahaha forget it.

29. There are a few things you can do whilst sailing that don't involve leaving the couch or dropping the controller. You have to be bright enough to think of them. Me, I simply make up lyrics to the sailing music.

30. US v Japan?

    Western V Japanese wind waker disc, ignorant Americans as usual.

This discussion is closed to new comments.