What character should Nintendo kill off?


50 Responses to What character should Nintendo kill off?

  1. Mattiac says:

    Waluigi, Tingle, Navi, Bowser and Ganon!

  2. Collin says:


  3. Amy says:

    How about none?:P

  4. Richard says:

    None. They’ve got few enough games coming out right now as it is! 🙂

  5. El Demonio says:

    I voted Kirby as he annoys the living daylights out of me, but, there are definitely over a hundred Pokemon species I wish would go extinct…

  6. Yellow Bear says:

    slippy the freaking frog

  7. chibikage89 says:

    They should kill off Sonic so they can resurrect him as one of there own. Hey you never said it had to be a Nintendo character.

  8. Russ says:

    I voted ‘other’ so I could join in the vote for none! Why would I ever want a game series taken away from me. If you don’t like a character why not just avoid the game?

  9. Mohan says:

    I’m with Collin, none!

  10. Harrison says:

    No one. But, if I had to pick one, I’d have to say at least the more generic of the 400+ Pokemon out there. Just a thought.

  11. JDK says:


    Zip, Zero, Nada, Nil!

  12. ModestMrGreen says:

    Kill Krystal from Star Fox, please. 😀

  13. John from Leicester, United Kingdom says:

    Tingle. He’s the only one.

  14. Diagoras Of Thebes says:


    I expect a lot of hate for this, but I feel it’s time for the Zelda franchise to take a break, and get a break so it can get its groove back.

  15. Diagoras Of Thebes says:

    And I didn’t even check my grammar. Great.

  16. Alvârö says:

    If I had to choose a character or franchise to be replaced by something new and fresh it would be Pokemon. Every new version (or color) is a pass for me…don’t get me wrong, I loved it back in the beginning with red and green…

  17. Malcolm says:

    They should kill off Luigi and have a game where Mario goes totally apeshit Agent 47 style on all of Bowser’s minions and henchmen before dispatching of the big man in the worst way possible…

    only to find out it was all a dream he had while in a coma. 🙂

  18. Brian says:

    Jack Tretton and Kaz Hirai. Booyah!!!

  19. MrMiyamoto says:

    Miis. Seriously Nintendo, one generation of those was enough. Either make some other avatar system or just stop putting them in crappy games like Pilotwings Resort. <_<

  20. GameCollector44 says:

    I wouldn’t kill off Pokemon entirely…I would love to get some more original creatures though.

    @MrMiyamoto: If you’re going to rag on Nintendo about Miis, then you gotta rag on Microsoft and Sony as well for having similar things to Miis. Can’t just pick on one company when others are doing it…although I do agree that some better games are needed using Miis….maybe they could do something like the Sims on Whu-Hu Island? 😀

    I’m not voting…there’s no ‘none’ option.

  21. Artefacto says:


  22. Nin3DS says:

    Depends what you mean. Series? None. Characters? Goodbye Tingle and Bowser Jr!

  23. Agamer908 says:

    The whole Nintendo gaming brand should be killed off. Nintendo has ment nothing to me since the N64. the Wii is nothing but a overpriced kid toy and the WiiU will be over hyped by fantards old people & soccer moms. No real gamer would be cought died with a Wii or WiiU (lol at WiiU by the way sounds like pii-you in like what stinks nintendo) Sony & Micosoft 4 ever.

  24. Richard says:


    Seriously, is your life so empty that you spend your time visiting fansites of companies that mean nothing to you, just to troll like a snotty ten year old?

    “Real gamers” play good games on any system without fear of peer pressure–And Wii’s had plenty of great games. You’re pathetic.

  25. gojiguy says:

    what a limited list to pick from…

    I’d say Samus. Metroid has been eating up all the spotlight (even with lackluster sales) that would/could be given to franchises like StarFox and F-Zero.

  26. Lord Lemmy says:

    None! Absolutely none! Not even the ones who are slightly more annoying, or have gone down tubes.

  27. Abdulla says:

    Kristel from star fox adventures..Eff her

  28. The_old_man_In_the_cave says:


  29. Richard says:

    I really can’t believe how many folks have voted for Nintendo to axe their biggest moneymaker. Pokemon pays the rent, people! 🙂

  30. Aikun2012 says:

    Characters? I don’t really care about those as much as the franchises themselves buddy.

    …. And my answer is: None. I want more franchise work NOW. We need some revitalizing in Nintendo franchises, immediately..

    Donkey Kong
    Pokemon *no more Mystery Dungeon and other action titles please*
    Fire Emblem

    And yeah, Zelda needs to take a break… Aonuma needs to get his creative ideas into another game franchise….

    Adding to this is my support for new franchises…

    Quite frankly, I want some sequels of Rare games to come to Nintendo… New Perfect Dark and Jet Force Gemini would be nice. (As long as they can beat Perfect Dark Zero)

  31. Nin3DS says:

    To Aikun2012… you do know that Pokemon has had as many good games now as it ever had? It’s almost always been one main game per console, and even then Pokemon Black and White shook up the formula.

    And well, the Donkey Kong’s already returned with Donkey Kong Country Returns.

    Agree with the others though.

  32. loser says:

    Pokemon belongs to GameFreak. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

  33. Duke says:

    None. All three are excellent.

  34. EdEN says:

    None… why would they have to?

  35. Duke says:

    But the new Black/White pkmn suck.

  36. Rob says:

    Pokemon needs to die. The the number just keeps getting larger, when I think the series should have died off after Gold and Silver. I may be like this since I was growing up when the Red and Blue first came out, but still. Once Pokemon hits 1000 (if not already), it’ll be a sad day.

  37. The Adza says:

    I didn’t even think of Zelda, but it would make a good story if she died in game. She could always come back in another game anyway.

    Killed off for good though? My vote goes to none. No one. Well, maybe Cranky Kong.

  38. tlomax3927 says:

    For characters: Navi (keep Midna!) and Tingle
    For franchises: Make new stories for Zelda and Mario.

  39. Hitokiri_Ace says:


  40. ghettoska says:

    Haha pikmin is pretty much killed off anyway. Last one came out almost eight years ago. I know they are working on a new one but still…

    And never played the earthbound/mother franchise so I would go with that one to die

  41. Sal says:

    Baby Mario, Luigi, peach, daisy, bowser and donkey kong jr… Sega is a different story

  42. Mattiac says:

    PS. Bowser Jr. too!

  43. -_Q says:

    So much Tingle and Bowser Jr. hate.

    I love Tingle and Bowser Jr.

    I love you guys.

  44. Cowmanodoom says:

    Tingle, Birdo, and Waluigi…

    I… absolutely… DESPISE them!

    Although Tingle can be kind of funny sometimes, even if it’s just because of how dumb and totally insane he is.

  45. WesFX says:

    If I had to pick a character to never see again, then I’d go with Captain Falcon. You barely see him anyway in “his” games.

  46. QQQ'S says:

    “50 years in the future”

    VEGETA, what does you scouter say about Nintendo’s Pokemon Level?
    ITS OVER 9000! “Crushes Scouter”

    Seriously though, I could see this kind of thing happening.
    And why Falcon? He’s the most hilarious smasher ever created. And that would mean no more FALCON PUNCH
    My character pick would have to be Slippy
    I'm tired of saving him Over 900 times per level!

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: